lawpalyer logo
in判決書

智慧財產及商業法院97年度民專訴字第32號

關鍵資訊

  • 裁判案由
    侵害專利權有關財產權爭議
  • 案件類型
    智財
  • 審判法院
    智慧財產及商業法院
  • 裁判日期
    98 年 04 月 06 日

  • 當事人
    甲○○兆田精密工業股份有限公司乙○○○

9732 98 316 971216259 260 1 3592439 4328948 2 150 5% 152957374427881111996 1630303131405060703060使603040使6030 airbone ZT702 airbone ZT705 使airbone ZT705 978 125 108 8485 244 1 4 150 313031' 3131' 30' A 31' A 30' 31' 60' 30' 60' A 40404040A A 40 A 40 A 40means functionresult 40A 40' 60' 30' 40A 40' 60' 30' 40A 40' M303973 973 7 2 5 A 50b 50'b50b A 40' 50'b4040' 70' A 30' 70' 50')60' 使40' 使A 40使7 1 5 100 6040403070使4030604030 973 7 2 5 A 40A 40' 603040使60305050a 50b 50'a50a 50'b50b A 60' 50' A 40' 973 50' 60' A 40 973 9705073 4 139 4050601 3 A 4 5 973 40973 3 A 50973 4 60973 5 40 4 106 1 使6 5 5 60973 5 40 5 310 40 973 973 40 977 4 8 1 963 30973 966 12973 966 12 876 178811119 10 A 30' 70' 60' 50' A 31' 31' 60' 50' 30' A 使30' 60' 60' 使50' 4040 30604050穿40A 31' 60' 40 A 40 4050304060' A 31' 40 973 973 973 554958973 554958 977 2 9711171 20086 20 973 使 調406030使603050穿60304050603040406030603060 Doctrine of equivalentway functionresults 6030603040A 31' 31' 973 310 60' 50' 穿30' A 40A 40 4060使603040使603030使306060306030406030603070使40304060使4030604060使604040 A 穿30' 60' A 70' A 60' 70' A 60' A 70' 使60' 70' A 70' A 70' A 50' A 40使6030406030使A 70' 60' 使A 40 (70') (A) 60' A 使 70' A 4 A 40603060306030使 40A 30506050穿6050A 161 2 406030603070使40304060使4030604060使604040退4030 便使6040162 966 12976 30 971 9 ZT705 75ZT702 240 315 432 977 2 19774 124,017,057 4017057 A coupling body 11) 60' A tubular resilient seal 24 70' connectingnut 13A 60' 70' 4017057 1977使 Scott Wu20014 246,220,836 6220836 6220836 claim 406030a protective ring 40 is mounted between the plug 60 and the sleeve for a full axial length of the plug such that the plug does not move the sleeve rotates 4017057 132411216220836 4017057 6220836 4017057 11A 2460' 1370' 4017057 4017057 152957374427881111996 16 30303131405060703060使603040使6030 airbone ZT702 airbone ZT705 5040airbone ZT-702airbone ZT-705 973 3030313140506070 3060使603040使60301 2 1 2 2 a 2 a 3 5 使5 1 31使5 1 2 1 1 5 2 A 1 10406030315 1 3 315 1 1 3 1 1 4 975 281 1 1 1 4 1 Doctrine of Equivalents substantial differenceway functionresult 1 4 3 Way FunctionResult 30+70 1+2 31104031605 30+70 1+2 使 605 使30+70 1+ 2 4031使605 1 4 50使使973 7 4 便使5060 3060使4060使60973 7 2 5 4031605 301 605 1 A 60' 70' 973 973 311 973 1 A 40' 50' 60' 60' 70' 403 2 1 973 4050 4017057 3592439 4328948 3 4017057 西19774 124017057 876 17 4017057 4 3 312 5 101 4 4017057 11131224162 4017057 1 4017057 4017057 11A 2460' 1370' 4017057 fluid 4017057 1 202322462 delevery of air 4017057 4017057 244017057 3 1 24605 60401705724 44使4017057 3592439 西19698 153592439 876 17 3592439 1 2 7 3592439 5 3 31 2 5 101 4 3592439 31363417) 37383 3592439 4328948 西19825 114328948 876 174328948 1 fluid 43289486 3 312 5 101 4 4328948 1 1747165 234 4328948 108 8485150 5% 565,200 5%25×35 1 977 2 5 977 148 12 貿GS-0 1 4 1 2 使 仿仿便便便 96973 973 973 973 使973 調 使 977 2 使191 977 2 22 使24 使192224977 2 ZT-720167 700 ZT-705551300188400(700*167+1300*55) 188400565,200 3425×351 973 963 30 97airbone ZT-702airbone ZT-705975 28976 277 4 7 5 airbone 8 1 976 27 便977 14240 8 238 1 978 12 976 27使3 4 使使使4 3 1 3 使 191 22243425×35 1 4017057 3592439 4328948 3 使調調3 1 3 使使使192224GS-01 使使使使3 1 3 4 1 976 27使3 4 使使使4 3 1 3 使 191 2224565,200 3425×351 78 98 4 6 20 98 4 6