lawpalyer logo
in判決書

臺灣高等法院 臺中分院111年度矚上訴字第993號

關鍵資訊

  • 裁判案由
    違反廢棄物清理法等
  • 案件類型
    刑事
  • 審判法院
    臺灣高等法院 臺中分院
  • 裁判日期
    112 年 02 月 22 日

  • 當事人
    臺灣彰化地方檢察署檢察官

111993 10911101129 108 79557956795779587959796079617962864686478648514498089809981298131047410987787887929452946393639371098730110842392049205 111 11530115311153211533 1041029104003-110677106003-21061012106003-3 108730108003-4D-0902D-1199 D-1099D-1103-0104S-0 106600 10f/² 滿 80090 901087 1088 11083 8391( )駿(駿) 0 00010700000000() 1008300000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 ( )106 1 061110710 11 1071225108220 10843 4500 106 ( )使 刺 ( 000) 使10727 10135601072 42509.871475804 1154540000 0000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000 使106 ( 160170) 51056010611108145556.925465976 106108101710611089駿2509.87 45556.93 01167.5641710189.55 使 31125 ( )使 42 242345(241071222 2510811 ) 錄 3錄 使使錄錄3 10 使 31125 使使 使 ( ) 1 ( ) 1061110884358.777 () ()( ) 錄 15171 1-3 使 107242509.871,475,804 115,454 4 10611108145556.9 2546597610712251082 205 22133.975 108730駿駿000 10711 1088131081017 1982081 1591K--00000000-0002 4 15911594調15911595調 108 1047430-351081047418-201081047474-8020-6710810474150-1581047411-1131047456-6068-81108104745-753-711081047484-8690-921081047479-8110810474 63-6910810474 66-7110810474149-1511081047474-76 1081047479-83135-143108104745-8 1081047420-22 1081047425-26 1081047429-30 1081047432-3436-371081047440-4244-451081047448-50 52-541081047457-591081047488-92 135-1431081047488-89108104744-810810474 84-89108864734-378647159-1601072728 73-771088647調212-21482-108 駿 使13-401072 710 10727109123113 使43-125106103110 10610311071231使使使使使107124使1071241081231 1071227 1071227108123110765107651091231 1061215 1071227 10814 駿 使108003-4使1061128 45106111081 45556.9 108102108104741-2810891089pH11.5pH11.689-93 108102A2B 45ApH13 mg/kg10810474 3-3482-88 1081047425-595-22 西西 1081112 102 108104741-22 駿108730駿6 D-0599D-07991072728 41-55921-23 駿駿 108813D pH11.1COD4,170mg/L9.10mg/LpH9.6 COD684mg/L1.68mg/LpH9.7pH12.414.3mg/L pH11.19.10mg/L1072728 146-14832-37 108830pH10.115.0mg/L45.4mg/L194mg/L26.4mg/L 1072728 10-3245-49 10891819CDE pH12.37 mg/kg 10727281-69674-81 1081218 使ABC94597.15ABCDE31141.32125738.471088648132-135111-116127-128 109317AB108 86482-5 駿駿 退41710189.55 107242509.87駿560 1475804 駿1072710 13駿26354 44-5113-14 10611108145556.922133.975 10160170 25465976560 10611089301167.56 45556.9駿 2509.87 駿0.8315.12 1 225 BC231 () DD-0902 ED-1099 FD-1103 GD-1199 HS-0104 IS-0106 106111088 10810474199207 D-0902 D-1099 D-1103 D-1199 S-0104 S-0106 106/11 5,532.811 244.790 511.020 464.590     6,753.211 6379.831 106/12 4,779.730 171.948 274.890 183.410     5,409.978 5315.82 107/01 4,866.024 414.210 195.030 140.600     5,615.864 5489.164 107/02 3,521.550 259.640 198.080 96.120   87.390 4,162.780 3950.67 107/03 4,338.620 344.820 461.950 206.900   25.180 5,377.470 5211.026 107/04 3,674.668 457.572 375.700 250.210   27.440 4,785.590 4642.34 107/05 3,745.273 864.874 436.780 275.640   299.940 5,622.507 5186.862 107/06 2,608.142 459.067 492.010 413.740   1.900 3,974.859 3886.119 107/07 3,120.987 620.838 363.060 581.670   19.580 4,706.135 4630.715 107/08 3,611.900 2,106.430 372.560 594.090 80.660   6,765.640 6229.91 107/09 3,494.406 1,742.764 339.230 815.800 18.980 1.660 6,412.840 6265.3 107/10 3,837.255 1,859.631 406.230 489.650   434.150 7,026.916 6389.276 107/11 2,459.215 1,704.976 421.530 608.180   109.000 5,302.901 5976.731 107/12 3,453.470 1,358.060 358.070 499.860   19.250 5,688.710 5485.4 108/01 2,632.231 1,589.814 410.030 669.250 178.860   5,480.185 6267.815 108/02 2,949.465 1,120.840 381.550 515.790     4,967.645 3854.885 108/03 3,653.408 961.100 306.120 1,018.170   2.460 5,941.258 5863.318 108/04 4,181.740 490.910 445.420 677.140 110.910   5,906.120 5697.22 108/05 4,552.825 605.080 356.960 788.180 536.090   6,839.135 6288.375 108/06 4,221.939 1,099.635 478.400 761.170     6,561.144 6210.854 108/07 4,370.387 1,595.359 394.410 1,094.720     7,454.876 7562.606 108/08 3,605.353 717.327 404.590 1,068.900 23.380 32.990 5,852.540 5465.29 126,608.304 122,249.527 106111088 4358.777126,608.304 122,249.527 4358.7773.444358.777÷126,608.3040.00000000 3.44435 8.777 10 9 91使1081047476 51020 1081047479-80 1081047464 0902D-090210212 1081047485 108104747 1081047450-54 106111088 4358.777 使211322221 使駿211 4 212 使213 使 駿駿196 駿500400使 駿駿 00 pH11.69.22mg/L12.9mg/L6.50mg/L2.51mg/L000 pH1382-93 212 使 31125 ()使 使 42 2412345(10712 222510811 )錄 3錄 使使錄錄3 10 使 196 使10810474174-177 使使10810474187 使使 錄 D SS-0104S-0106 ( )使 106112使107112使10818使10810474196-1981081047417-18 ABACADAE A AB  / () 使 106/01 1,202.54 2,170.589 106/02 1,841.06 2,141.823 106/03 1,684.60 2,265.186 106/04 1,362.40 1,146.675 106/05 1,038.10 1,166.640 106/06 1,181.60 1,205.023 106/07 1,344.64 1,342.006 106/08 1,270.30 1,274.466 106/09 1,272.38 1,299.250 106/10 1,375.66 1,360.635 106/11 1,361.40 1,355.879 106/12 1,632.50 1,604.852 107/01 1,604.68 1,610.040 107/02 1,618.48 1,606.759 107/03 1,736.22 1,554.932 107/04 1,505.68 1,510.676 107/05 1,534.14 1,216.987 107/06 923.06 887.828 107/07 1,058.71 1,054.448 107/08 1,358.31 1,251.594 107/09 1,263.14 1,284.145 107/10 1,128.03 1,174.455 107/11 1,246.13 1,285.496 107/12 1,310.49 1,259.198 108/01 1,021.40 1,278.413 108/02 1,216.47 1,239.387 108/03 1,063.09 284.054 108/04 1,363.11 1,317.147 108/05 1,439.36 1,288.807 108/06 1,456.66 1,205.122 108/07 1,423.25 1,274.178 108/08 1,346.71 1,412.124 43,184.30 43,328.814 43184.30使43328.814使144.514 A AC AD /  68 使 106/01     1,388.861 106/02 2,437 29,278 1,248.424 106/03     1,049.811 106/04 3,241 38,985 1,023.899 106/05     1,043.034 106/06 3,711 44,661 1,172.843 106/07     975.042 106/08 4,131 49,732 1,065.748 106/09     1,223.296 106/10 1,634 19,581 1,223.296 106/11     1,175.480 106/12 1,307 15,633 1,122.471 107/01     1,195.200 107/02 896 11,664 1,191.758 107/03     1,140.644 107/04 896 11,660 1,213.646 107/05 430 5,750 1,169.405 107/06 789 10,308 886.298 107/07     1,013.339 107/08 2,189 28,057 1,322.077 107/09     1,327.575 107/10 2,395 30,663 1,233.407 107/11     1,320.830 107/12 2,474 31,667 1,198.299 108/01     1,300.223 108/02 2,002 25,692 1,178.097 108/03     1,229.461 108/04 2,121 27,192 1,149.592 108/05     1,125.083 108/06 2,590 33,147 1,033.105 108/07     1,232.208 108/08 3,814 48,662 1,366.899 37,057 37,539.351 37,057使37,539.351使482.351 A AE /  () 使 106/01 0.000 130.249 106/02 97.430 126.433 106/03 65.370 81.893 106/04 18.570 30.085 106/05 29.560 26.027 106/06 19.390 27.654 106/07 39.590 29.491 106/08 28.810 24.712 106/09 22.210 26.701 106/10 28.270 29.304 106/11 31.270 32.103 106/12 20.300 30.553 107/01 31.000 30.584 107/02 20.940 31.841 107/03 30.620 29.957 107/04 21.150 29.134 107/05 20.940 26.614 107/06 20.590 19.635 107/07 31.120 23.599 107/08 20.620 25.723 107/09 31.000 27.068 107/10 0.000 24.435 107/11 20.520 26.957 107/12 0.000 27.097 108/01 0.000 27.554 108/02 0.000 28.798 108/03 0.000 28.235 108/04 0.000 30.888 108/05 30.900 29.44 108/06 0.000 28.566 108/07 29.960 27.405 108/08 41.600 31.548 751.730 1150.283 751.730使1150.283 使398.553 211-219 1 106.11 12,408.99 12,408.99 2 106.12 946.679 10,682.66 3 107.01 2,506.823 7,406.96 4 107.02 1,099.85 1,099.85 5 107.03 2,621.425 7,566.09 6 107.04 1,307.508 5,149.65 7 107.12 241.81 241.81 8 108.01 1,000.89 1000.89 9 22,133.975 45,556.9 西 20% 15%5% 1081047431-35 20% 75108 1047457-60 17%17%20% 20% 1081047475-80 17% 108104746 退 O-28107 126 退7 464 104 使464 駿464 266 711 560 151 711 483113128 使104 16844848215 215 462 4612462 936517 462 2412462 244644621033762 462 462 462 1.464 2.464 47 3. 1.48711 48711215215 2.711 311 3.3 311 48 464 411 464 411 111241) 使 711 15 171 5 131631642913 464 4855464 38233814381123203 46448 464 4644711111229 57 11183674調 滿--4 5556.9駿2509.87 10 () 107514駿2509.87 7424 3811234 調3822調45526145527 1061 108941710189 10611089301,167.56382241,710,18935,399,437(301,167.5645556.92 55,610.66255,610.66÷301,167.560.848 741,710,189×0.848735,399,437.4043 3815 111115301153111 53211533 (108003-4)D-0902D-1199D-1099D-1103-0104 S-010610/cm2DS4,000 8,00031125使10610871414810611088139,816,737490,83810611086153,447,526172,37610641195,4739,773 106110883 2913,459,7363 使1061108820527.5982,110,3226946.19 456 使D-0902106 510550(170) 106111071244,556.01 22133.975 24,874,91389,811,716490,587 5114,441,593722,080 71148 2- 3 4561 46144871147141461448711 431 461448711 47141 431 89,811,716490,587 5114,441,593722,080 741533 36913642991455261464474871111 2831155741124381123343822         112    2     22                       112    2     22   46 47 48 71 使簿 簿 使 使 1.15 1 106110 MP00000000 466,646 23,332 489,978 2 106131 MP00000000 1,442,475 72,124 1,514,599 3 106228 MP00000000 745,223 37,261 782,484 4 106331 NE00000000 1,247,670 62,384 1,310,054 5 107531 CL00000000 544,005 27,200 571,205 6 1071031 GE00000000 1,519,335 75,967 1,595,302 7 1071031 GE00000000 212,014 10,601 222,615 8 1071130 JB00000000 251,088 12,554 263,642 9 1071231 JB00000000 1,200,000 60,000 1,260,000 10 108228 KY00000000 120,451 6,023 126,474 11 108331 MV00000000 633,190 31,660 664,850 12 108630 PS00000000 1,442,445 72,122 1,514,567 13 108731 RP00000000 178,176 8,909 187,085 14 108731 RP00000000 1,200,000 60,000 1,260,000 15 108831 RP00000000 600,000 30,000 630,000 1015 2.17 1 10611 MP00000000 206,467 10,323 216,790 2 106123 MP00000000 1,385,374 69,269 1,454,643 3 106126 MP00000000 630,966 31,548 662,514 4 10623 MP00000000 228,060 11,403 239,463 5 10629 MP00000000 221,001 11,050 232,051 6 10628 MP00000000 189,688 9,484 199,172 7 106328 NE00000000 189,326 9,466 198,792 8 1061229 QS00000000 198,120 9,906 208,026 9 107331 AN00000000 201,045 10,052 211,097 10 107425 AN00000000 206,310 10,316 216,626 11 1071030 GE00000000 590,140 29,507 619,647 12 1071228 JB00000000 593,750 29,688 623,438 13 108131 KY00000000 605,170 30,259 635,429 14 108222 KY00000000 593,750 29,688 623,438 15 108330 MV00000000 594,320 29,716 624,036 16 108430 MV00000000 585,580 29,279 614,859 17 108626 PS00000000 592,800 29,640 622,440 3.1 1 106425 NH00000000 319,808 15,990 335,798 4.5 1 107216 YR00000000 65,996 3,300 69,296 2 10731 AN00000000 429,436 21,472 450,908 3 107323 AN00000000 350,638 17,532 368,170 4 10741 AN00000000 254,806 12,740 267,546 5 107422 AN00000000 304,651 15,233 319,884 5.15613 13 1 1061115 QS00000000 2,881,694 144,085 3,025,779 2 1061125 QS00000000 3,446,891 172,345 3,619,236 3 1061215 QS00000000 3,117,069 155,853 3,272,922 4 10712 YR00000000 2,651,567 132,578 2,784,145 5 107115 YR00000000 2,344,372 117,219 2,461,591 6 107116 YR00000000 1,655,386 82,769 1,738,155 7 107216 YR00000000 593,919 29,696 623,615 8 107314 AN00000000 2,380,136 119,007 2,499,143 9 107325 AN00000000 1,705,552 85,278 1,790,830 10 107417 AN00000000 1,378,652 68,933 1,447,585 11 10741 AN00000000 1,402,159 70,108 1,472,267 12 1071226 JB00000000 135,414 6,771 142,185 13 108115 KY00000000 560,498 28,025 588,523