The addressee of preliminary findings pursuant to Article 34(1) of Regulation (EU) 2022/1925 may, within the time-limit set by the Commission pursuant to Article 34(2) of that Regulation, succinctly and in accordance with the format and length requirements for documents set out in Annex II to this Regulation, inform the Commission of its views in writing and submit evidence in support thereof. The Commission shall not be obliged to take account of written submissions received after the expiry of that time-limit.
Identification and protection of confidential information
1. Unless otherwise provided for in Regulation (EU) 2022/1925 or Article 8 of this Regulation and without prejudice to paragraph 6 of this Article, information or documents collected or obtained by the Commission shall not be disclosed or made accessible by the Commission in so far as they contain business secrets or other confidential information of any natural or legal person.
2. When requesting information pursuant to Article 21 of Regulation (EU) 2022/1925 or, carrying out interviews pursuant to Article 22 of Regulation (EU) 2022/1925, the Commission shall inform the relevant natural or legal persons that, by providing information to the Commission, they agree that access to that information may be granted pursuant to Article 8 of this Regulation. In any event, the provisions of Article 8 shall apply to any document spontaneously submitted to the Commission under Regulation (EU) 2022/1925 or this Regulation.
3. Without prejudice to paragraph 2, the Commission may require natural or legal persons who are the originators of documents in its file to identify the documents, statements or parts thereof which they consider to contain business secrets or other confidential information. The Commission may also set a time-limit for natural or legal persons to identify any part of a Commission decision which in their view contains business secrets or other confidential information.
4. The Commission may set a time-limit for natural or legal persons to:
(a)
substantiate in a specific manner their claims for business secrets and other confidential information for each individual document, statement or part thereof;
(b)
provide the Commission with a non-confidential version of the documents or statements in which the business secrets and other confidential information are redacted in a clear and intelligible manner;
(c)
provide a concise, non-confidential and clear description of each piece of redacted information.
5. If natural or legal persons fail to comply within the time-limit set by the Commission with a request pursuant to paragraph 3 or 4, the Commission may consider that the documents or statements concerned do not contain business secrets or other confidential information.
6. If the Commission determines that certain information that is claimed confidential by a natural or legal person may be disclosed, either because this information does not constitute a business secret or other confidential information, or because there is an overriding interest in its disclosure, it shall inform the natural or legal person concerned that it intends to disclose such information unless it receives objections within one week. Should the natural or legal person in question object, the Commission may adopt a reasoned decision specifying the date after which the information will be disclosed. This date shall not be less than one week from the date of notification. The decision shall be notified to the natural or legal person concerned.
7. Unless otherwise indicated by the Commission, any comments by third parties on a publication or consultation pursuant to Article 8(6), Article 18(5) and (6), Article 19(2) and Article 29(4) of Regulation (EU) 2022/1925 shall be treated as non-confidential. Interested third parties submitting comments shall have the right to request the redaction of the author’s and the sender’s name or other identifying information before the comments are shared with the addressee of the preliminary findings or with any other third party. The Commission may make those comments, or any non-confidential version thereof, publicly available, provided it has indicated this possibility in the context of the publication or consultation.
1. Upon request, the Commission shall grant access to the file to the undertaking or association of undertakings to which it has addressed preliminary findings pursuant to Article 34(1) of Regulation (EU) 2022/1925 (the “addressee”). Access to the file shall not be granted before the notification of the preliminary findings.
2. When providing access to the file, the Commission shall provide the addressee with all documents mentioned in the preliminary findings, subject to redactions that have been made pursuant to Article 7(3) in order to protect business secrets or other confidential information.
3. Without prejudice to paragraph 4, the Commission shall also provide access to all documents on its file, without any redactions, under terms of disclosure to be set out in a Commission decision. The terms of disclosure shall be determined in accordance with the following:
(a)
Access to documents shall only be granted to a limited number of specified external legal and economic counsel and external technical experts engaged by the addressee and whose names shall be communicated to the Commission in advance.
(b)
The specified external legal and economic counsel and external technical experts shall be undertakings, employees of undertakings or in a situation comparable to that of employees of undertakings. All of them shall be bound by the terms of disclosure.
(c)
Persons listed as specified external legal and economic counsel and external technical experts shall not, at the date of the Commission decision setting out the terms of disclosure, be in an employment relationship with the addressee or in a situation comparable to that of an employee of the addressee. Should the specified external legal or economic counsel or external technical experts subsequently enter into such a relationship with the addressee or with other undertakings active on the same markets as the addressee during the investigation or during the three years following the end of the Commission’s investigation, the specified external legal or economic counsel or external technical expert and the addressee shall promptly inform the Commission about the terms of such relationship. The specified external legal or economic counsel or external technical expert in question shall also provide the Commission with an assurance that they no longer have access to the information or documents on the file to which they were given access according to point (a) and which were not made available to the addressee by the Commission. They shall also provide assurances to the Commission that they will continue to comply with the requirements referred to in point (d) of this paragraph.
(d)
Specified external legal and economic counsel and external technical experts shall not disclose any of the documents provided or their content to any natural or legal person that is not bound by the terms of disclosure and shall not use any of the documents provided or their content other than for the purposes referred to in Article 8(8) below.
(e)
The Commission shall specify, in the terms of disclosure, the technical means of the disclosure and its duration. Disclosure may be made by electronic means or (for some or all documents) physically at the Commission’s premises.
4. In exceptional circumstances the Commission may decide not to grant access to certain documents or to grant access to partly redacted documents under the terms of disclosure referred to in paragraph 3 if it determines that the harm that the party that submitted the documents in question would likely suffer from disclosure under those terms would, on balance, outweigh the importance of the disclosure of the full document for the exercise of the right to be heard. Without prejudice to Article 34(4), fourth and fifth sentences, of Regulation (EU) 2022/1925, the Commission may for the same reason decide not to disclose or partly disclose correspondence between the Commission and public authorities of the Member States or of third countries and other types of sensitive documents.
5. The specified external legal and economic counsel and external technical experts referred to in paragraph 3 may, within one week of receiving access to the file under the terms of disclosure, make a reasoned request to the Commission for access to a non-confidential version of any document on the Commission’s file not already provided to the addressee under paragraph 2, with a view to making such non-confidential version available to the addressee, or for an extension of the terms of disclosure to additional specified external legal and economic counsel or external technical experts. Such additional access or extension may only be granted exceptionally and provided that it is shown to be indispensable for the proper exercise of the addressee’s right to be heard.
6. For the purposes of applying paragraph 4 or 5, the Commission may request the party that submitted the documents in question to provide a non-confidential version thereof pursuant to Article 7(3) and (4).
7. Where the Commission considers a request under paragraph 5 to be well-founded in view of the need to ensure that the addressee is in a position to exercise its right to be heard effectively, the Commission shall request the party that submitted the documents in question either to agree to making a non-confidential version available to the addressee or to agree to the extension of the terms of disclosure to specified individuals or undertakings for the documents in question only. In the event that the party that submitted the documents in question does not agree, the Commission shall adopt a decision setting out the terms of disclosure for the documents in question.
8. Documents obtained through access to the file pursuant to this Article shall only be used for the purposes of the relevant proceedings within which access to those documents was given or of administrative or judicial proceedings concerning the application of Regulation (EU) 2022/1925 that are related to those proceedings.
9. At any time during the procedure, the Commission may instead of or in combination with the method of granting access to the file pursuant to paragraph 3 above, give access to some or all documents redacted pursuant to Article 7(3) in order to avoid a disproportionate delay or administrative burden.