lawpalyer logo
in判決書

臺灣高等法院97年度上訴字第1470號

關鍵資訊

        971470       8 96276397131 965899 使CHEN 使93119412使使使使使 簿 957128335 1 使使216210使3391使使210 942375932 使216 210使 使216 210使 使使339 1 3392使使使56使使55使12567 96424 96213 92103106-107101 14,385,294260 使CHEN4CHEN 219 36913642991212856 552162103391339 212191196 2137         97    6     6                    97    6     6    210 5 216 使210215使 339 使51 使 3392 31 使 1 J1 96 7 P3 95調 2763 188 2 J2 96 8 P4 95 3789 4441 3 J3 96 9 P5 95 1022 9810 4 J4 96 10 P6 95 353 2204 5 P1 96 11 P7 95 5899 9898 6 P2 95 12 P8 95 1677 8105 / / / 19311 5 243,5381P3 VISA 51 0000000000000000 0 1 9311 8 34,018 1P4 3 P45 000000000000 0 1 9312 17 122,6402P2 VISA 30 0000000000000000 0 1 2943 7 433,8251P8 VISA 77 0000000000000000 252,695簿 1 943 30 55,117 1P8 VISA 145 942 0000000000000000 60,396 P826 1 78941 9312 944 11 16,236 1P8 P826 VISA 24 120,992P8 1 27 35 944 15 299,6002P8 VISA 30 0000000000000000 45,075 1 2P8 31 0000000000000000 1 2P8 30 000000000000 1 9410 3 273,0952P8 VISA 42 0 1 9410 20 149,934 0000000000000000 186,1817P869-71 75 1 9411 7 155,8842P7 LITE 15 -16 157,032 1 9412 26 79,551 2P8 JCB 34 101,902 1 39412 1 130,413 3P1 VISA 19 0000000000000000 103,094 CHEN1 9411 14VISA 99,159 1P1 0000000000000000 27-28 111,611P12030 CHEN1 94910 P1 21 49411 姿 21VISA 103,5721P1 0000000000000000 41-42 111,150 1 P144 59312 17 210,0002P3 96 0000000000000000 210,000 1 9310 8 VISA 277,0002P3 P3113 0000000000000000 93 938910 277,000 1 P311 2113 0000000000000000 9311 2 VISA 164,7232P3 107-108 202,355 1 938 379,1461P3 VISA 52 0000000000000000 172,436 1 6941 31 219,8431P5 33 0000000000000000 109,320簿 1 943 1 34,591 1P6 17 34,591 1 P520 93111294 943 1 16MASTER 69,000 2P5 P5 0000000000000000 4 1920 69,000 1 9411 VISA 114,2022P5 11 0 1 942 VISA 54,733 1 0000000000000000 J41821 -22 49,871 0000000000000000 1 7941 31VISA 350,4291 0000000000000000 P556 168,117簿 1 949 23VISA 170,8322 P510 0 1 941 141,513 2 222 0000000000000000 J42529 0000000000000000 141,388 0000000000000000 1 2684,206 4385,294 VISA0000000000000000 (/ () ) 1 93.11.16- 14,700 P354-64 2 93.11.1628,500 P354-64 3 93.11.17 5,550 P354-64 4 93.11.19 20,000ATM P354-64 5 93.11.20 20,000ATM P354-64 6 93.11.20 16,000 P354-64 7 93.12.17 2,127 P354-64 8 93.12.2420,000ATM P354-64 9 93.12.25 20,000ATM P354-64 1093.12.25 10,192 P354-64 1193.12.26 30,000 P354-64 1294.1.1 20,000 P354-64 1394.1.7 1/12 830 P354-64 1494.1.10 1/24 579 P354-64 1594.2.21 610 P354-64 1694.1.7 2/12 830 P354-64 1794.1.10 2/24 579 P354-64 1894.1.7 3/12 830 P354-64 1994.1.10 3/24 579 P354-64 2094.4.11 5,000ATM P354-64 2194.4.11 3,000ATM P354-64 2294.4.17 2,000ATM P354-64 2394.4.17 2,000ATM P354-64 2494.1.7 4/12 830 P354-64 2594.1.10 4/24 579 P354-64 2694.1.7 5/12 830 P354-64 2794.1.10 5/24 579 P354-64 2894.1.7 5,810 P354-64 2994.1.10 11,004 P354-64 243,538 000000000000 (/ () ) 1 93.12.9 ATM 10,006ATM P47-9 2 93.12.14ATM 9,000ATM P47-9 3 94.2.24 ATM 5,006ATM P47-9 4 94.3.7 ATM 10,006ATM P47-9 34,018 0000000000000000 (/ () ) 1 94.1.12 540 J3114-123 2 94.1.14 20,000ATM J3114-123 3 94.1.14 20,000ATM J3114-123 4 94.1.17 11,100 J3114-123 5 94.1.17 20,000ATM J3114-123 6 94.1.17 20,000ATM J3114-123 7 94.1.19 20,000ATM J3114-123 8 94.1.19 5,000ATM J3114-123 9 94.4.12 1,000ATM J3114-123 1094.4.12 5,000ATM J3114-123 122,640 VISA0000000000000000 (/ () ) 1 94.3.19 12,105 P879-100 2 94.3.18 980 P879-100 3 94.3.20 6,152 P879-100 4 94.3.20 395 P879-100 5 94.3.20 20,000 P879-100 6 94.3.20 450 P879-100 7 94.3.20 5,704 P879-100 8 94.3.26 10,000ATM P879-100 9 94.3.26 20,000ATM P879-100 1094.3.26 20,000ATM P879-100 1194.3.26 20,000ATM P879-100 1294.3.26 20,000ATM P879-100 1394.4.2 750 P879-100 1494.4.2 4,990 P879-100 1594.4.3 13,664 P879-100 1694.4.4 5,000 P879-100 1794.4.3 500 P879-100 1894.4.3 500 P879-100 1994.4.3 8,784 P879-100 2094.3.27 300 P879-100 2194.5.23 20,000ATM P879-100 2294.5.23 670 P879-100 2394.7.5 4,000ATM P879-100 2494.8 1,000ATM P879-100 2594.8 2,000ATM P879-100 2694.8 1,333 P879-100 1/12 2794.8.31 6,000ATM P879-100 2894.8.1 1,333 P879-100 2/12 2994.8.1 1,333 P879-100 3/12 3094.11.4 6,500 P879-100 1/24 3194.11.8 750 P879-100 1/24 3294.8.1 1,333 P879-100 4/12 3394.8.1 120 P879-100 4/12 3494.11.30 39,000ATM P879-100 3594.11.4 6,500 P879-100 2/24 3694.11.8 750 P879-100 2/24 3794.8.1 1,333 P879-100 5/12 3894.11.4 6,500 P879-100 3/24 3994.11.8 750 P879-100 3/24 4094.8.1 1,333 P879-100 6/12 4194.8.1 1,333 P879-100 7/12 4294.11.4 6,500 P879-100 4/24 4394.11.8 750 P879-100 4/24 4494.8.1 1,333 P879-100 8/12 454.11.4 5/24 6,500 P879-100 4694.11.8 750 P879-100 5/24 4794.11.4 123,500 P879-100 4894.8.1 5,333 P879-100 4994.11.8 14,250 P879-100 433,825 VISA0000000000000000 (/ () ) 1 94.5.5 - 1,331 J362-77 2 94.5.6 500ATM J362-77 3 94.5.5 - 3,250 J362-77 4 94.6.3 - 1,331 J362-77 5 94.6.3 - 3,250 J362-77 6 94.7.5 - 1,331 J362-77 7 94.7.5 - 3,250 J362-77 8 94.8.5 - 1,331 J362-77 9 94.8.5 - 3,250 J362-77 1094.8.8 5,000 J362-77 1194.9.5 - 1,331 J362-77 1294.9.5 - 3,250 J362-77 1394.10.4 1,300ATM J362-77 1494.10.5 - 3,250 J362-77 1594.10.5 - 1,331 J362-77 1694.11.4 - 3,250 J362-77 1794.12.5 - 3,250 J362-77 1894.12.29 1,331ATM J362-77 1995.1.5 - 3,250 J362-77 2095.2.3 - 3,250 J362-77 2195.3.3 - 3,250 J362-77 2294.4.4 - 3,250 J362-77 55,117 VISA (/ () ) 1 94.9.4 10,926 P8 2 94.10.19 2,270 P8 3 94.10.19 3,040 P8 16,236 A VISA0000000000000000 B 0000000000000000 C 000000000000 (/ () ) 1 94.5.8 520 A(P83272) 2 94.5.9 27,280 A(P83272) 3 94.5.10 1,670 A(P83272) 1/6 4 94.5.17 ATM 5,000ATM A(P83272) 5 94.5.17 ATM 10,000ATM A(P83272) 6 94.5.17 ATM 10,000ATM A(P83272) 7 94.5.17 ATM 20,000ATM A(P83272) 8 94.5.17 ATM 20,000ATM A(P83272) 9 94.6.10 1,666 A(P83272) 2/6 1094.7.11 1,666 A(P83272) 3/6 1194.8.10 2,000ATM A(P83272) 1294.8.10 2,000ATM A(P83272) 1394.8.10 1,666 A(P83272) 4/6 1494.9.12 1,666 A(P83272) 5/6 1594.10.11 1,666 A(P83272) 6/6 1694.11.10 20,000ATM A(P83272) 1794.11.1020,000ATM A(P83272) 1894.11.1020,000ATM A(P83272) 1994.11.1017,000ATM A(P83272) 2094.7.1 1/60 2,152 B(P832 ) 2194.8.1 2/60 2,186 B(P832 ) 2294.9.1 3/60 2,219 B(P832 ) 2394.10.3 4/60 2,254 B(P832 ) 2494.11.1 5/60 2,288 B(P832 ) 2594.12.1 6/60 2,324 B(P832 ) 2695.1.2 7/60 2,359 B(P832 ) 2795.2.2 8/60 2,396 B(P832 ) 2895.3.1 9/60 2,433 B(P832 ) 2995.4.3 2,470 B(P832 ) 10/60 3095.4.12 186,919 B(P832 ) 3194.5.12 ATM 30,000ATM C(P880 ) 3294.5.12 ATM 30,000ATM C(P880 ) 3394.7.13 ATM 3,000ATM C(P880 ) 3494.8.10 ATM 600ATM C(P880 ) 3594.9.15 ATM 20,000ATM C(P880 ) 3694.9.15 ATM 1,000ATM C(P880 ) 3794.11.17ATM 3,000ATM C(P880 ) 3895.1.23 ATM 1,000ATM C(P880 ) 3995.1.23 ATM 1,000ATM C(P880 ) 299,600 VISA (/ () ) 1 94.10.19-- 998 P845-67 2 94.10.19-- 1580 P845-67 3 94.10.2116,000 ATM P845-67 4 94.10.17 599 P845-67 5 94.10.17 1,118 P845-67 6 94.10.17 3,300 P845-67 7 94.8.2 14,000ATM P845-67 8 94.6.22 7,000ATM P845-67 9 94.4.14 5,000ATM P845-67 1094.4.14 10,000ATM P845-67 1193.12.2 10,000ATM P845-67 1293.12.2 10,000ATM P845-67 1395.3.20 B 193,500 P845-67 273,095 0000000000000000 (/ () ) 1 94.10.28 95,835 P713 2 94.10.28 50,000 P713 3 94.12.3 -- 1,100 P713 4 94.12.3 -- 999 P713 5 94.12.26 2,000ATM P713 149,934 LITE (/ () ) 1 94.11.12 119,892 P717-30 2 94.11.14 29,992 P717-30 3 95.1.26 6,000 P717-30 155,884 JCB (/ () ) 1 95.1.6 840 P837-39 2 95.1.7 894 P837-39 3 95.1.8 1,180 P837-39 4 95.1.8 -- 2,550 P837-39 5 95.1.7 2,000 P837-39 6 95.1.7 70,600 P837-39 7 95.1.14 1,487 P837-39 79,551 VISA0000000000000000 (/ () ) 1 94.12.11 5,676 CHEN J2.55 /2231 2 94.12.15 7,800 CHEN J2.62 /1440 3 94.12.15 11,800 CHEN J2.62 /1605 4 94.12.16 5,500 CHEN J2.64() /1925 5 94.12.17 1,446 CHEN J2.20 /1419 6 94.12.17 2,480 CHEN J2.21 /1441 7 94.12.21 351 CHEN J2.67 /1316 8 94.12.21 5,866 CHEN J2.81 /2044 9 94.12.28 24,380 CHEN J2.22 /2036 1095.1.12 1,988 CHEN J2.23 /1320 1195.1.28 988 CHEN J2.24 /1242 1295.3.24 1,051 CHEN J2.25 /2029 1395.3.24 690 CHEN J2.26 /2041 1495.3.24 570 CHEN J2.78 /2118 1595.3.25 1,144 CHEN J2.27 /1247 1695.3.26 1,071 CHEN J2.28 /1834 1795.3.26 1,129 CHEN J2.29 /1841 1894.12.15 808 CHEN J27-9 1994.12.24 2,890 CHEN J27-9 2094.12.24 4,862 CHEN J27-9 2194.12.24 2,600 CHEN J27-9 2294.12.25滿 1,012 CHEN J27-9 2394.12.28 24,380 CHEN J27-9 2495.1.4 1,360 CHEN J27-9 2595.1.6 4,210 CHEN J27-9 2695.1.8 2,385 CHEN J27-9 2795.1.11 -- 245 CHEN J27-9 2895.1.18 1,531 CHEN J27-9 2995.1.26 89 10,200 CHEN J27-9 130,413 VISA0000000000000000 (/ () ) 1 94.12.2 5,000ATM J211 2 94.12.2 20,000ATM J211 3 94.12.2 10,000ATM J211 4 94.12.3 22,359 J211 5 95.1.9 89 18,000 J212 6 95.1.9 89 22,800 J212 7.95.1.22 1,000ATM J212 99,159 VISA0000000000000000 (/ () ) 1 94.12.3 5,122 P145-55 2 94.12.3 6,790 P145-55 3 94.12.3 8,622 P145-55 4 94.12.5 15,000ATM P145-55 5 94.12.5 418 P145-55 6 94.12.5 20,000ATM P145-55 7 94.12.10 743 P145-55 8 94.12.10 3,717 P145-55 9 94.12.18 4,400 P145-55 1 1096.1.1 827 P145-55 1196.1.1 2,464 P145-55 1296.1.1 4,469 P145-55 1395.12.18 4,400 P145-55 2 1495.1.22 5,000ATM P145-55 1595.1.26 89 17,200 P145-55 1694.12.18 4,400 P145-55 3 103,572 VISA 0000000000000000 0000000000000000 ( (/ ) ) 1 94.2.25 ATM 20,000 ATM J380P399 2 94.2.25 ATM 20,000 ATM J380P399 3 94.2.25 ATM 20,000 ATM J380P399 4 94.2.25 ATM 20,000 ATM J380P399 5 94.2.25 ATM 20,000 ATM J380P399 6 94.7.6 15,000 ATM J380P399 7 94.7.27 2,000 ATM J380P399 8 94.7.27 2,000 ATM J380P399 9 94.7.27 3,000 ATM J380P399 1094.7.27 5,000 ATM J380P399 1193.10.19 20,000 J380P399 1293.10.19 130,000 J380P399 277,000 0000000000000000 (/ () ) 1 94.1.31 1/60 2,152 J380P399 2 94.3.1 2/60 2,186 J380P399 3 94.3.31 3/60 2,219 J380P399 4 94.5.3 4/60 2,254 J380P399 5 94.5.31 5/60 2,288 J380P399 6 94.6.30 6/60 2,324 J380P399 7 94.8.1 7/60 2,359 J380P399 8 94.8.31 8/60 2,396 J380P399 9 94.9.30 9/60 2,433 J380P399 1094.10.3110/60 2,470 J380P399 1194.11.3011/60 2,508 J380P399 1295.1.2 12/60 2,547 J380P399 1395.2.2 13/60 2,586 J380P399 1495.3.1 14/60 2,626 J380P399 1595.3.31 15/60 2,667 J380P399 1695.4.3 173,985 J380P399 210,000 VISA ( (/ ) ) 1 94.8.22 6 3,828 J393-113 2 94.9.29 6 3,847 J393-113 3 94.10.216 3,866 J393-113 4 94.11.226 3,414 J393-113 5 94.12.236 3,455 J393-113 6 95.1.20 6 3,497 J393-113 7 95.2.22 6 3,539 J393-113 8 95.3.22 6 3,582 J393-113 9 95.4.17 6 135,369 J393-113 1094.9 66,909 J393-113 164,723 VISA0000000000000000 (/ () ) 1 93.8.11 30,000 J365-89 2 93.8.11 32,680 J365-89 3 93.8.11 65,000 J365-89 4 93.8.13 1,000 J365-89 5 93.8.13 1,880 J365-89 6 93.8.13 2,000 J365-89 7 93.9.7 7,376 J365-89 8 93.11.6 1/24 6,125 J365-89 9 93.11.6 2/24 6,125 J365-89 1093.11.6 3/24 6,125 J365-89 1193.11.6 4/24 6,125 J365-89 1293.11.6 5/24 6,125 J365-89 1393.11.6 6/24 6,125 J365-89 1493.11.6 7/24 6,125 J365-89 1593.11.6 8/24 6,125 J365-89 1694.6.10 28,460 J365-89 1793.11.6 9/24 6,125 J365-89 1894.7.7 16,000 J365-89 1993.11.6 10/24 6,125 J365-89 2094.8.24 20,000ATM J365-89 2194.9.11 11,000ATM J365-89 2293.11.6 11/24 6,125 J365-89 2393.11.6 12/24 6,125 J365-89 2493.11.6 13/24 6,125 J365-89 2594.11.2 6,000ATM J365-89 2694.11.17 5,000ATM J365-89 2794.12.1814/24 6,125 J365-89 2894.12.20 5,000ATM J365-89 2995.1.11 13,000ATM J365-89 3093.11.6 15/24 6,125 J365-89 3195.3.6 16/24 6,125 J365-89 3295.4.6 24/24 6,125 J365-89 3395.4.13 42,875 J365-89 379,146 Master Card 0000000000000000 (/ () ) 1 94.2.18 20,000ATM P535-43 2 94.12.1820,000ATM P535-43 3 94.2.21 20,000ATM P535-43 4 94.2.22 20,000ATM P535-43 5 94.2.25 18,000ATM P535-43 6 94.4.21 2,000ATM P535-43 7 94.4.21 3,000ATM P535-43 8 94.4.23 2,000ATM P535-43 9 94.7.6 5,000ATM P535-43 1094.7.27 3,000ATM P535-43 1194.10.22 270 P535-43 1294.10.22 1,860 P535-43 1394.10.22 3,460 P535-43 1494.10.30 3,333 P535-43 1/6 1594.10.28 36,000 P535-43 1694.11.1420,000ATM P535-43 1794.11.15 9,000ATM P535-43 1894.11.16 5,000ATM P535-43 1994.11.17 1,170 P535-43 2094.11.30 3,333 P535-43 2/6 2194.12.30 3,333 P535-43 3/6 2295.1.23 PC HOME 1,148 P535-43 2395.1.23 PC HOME 1,399 P535-43 2495.1.30 3,333 P535-43 4/6 2595.2.6 1,688 P535-43 2695.2.6 89 5,850 P535-43 2795.2.28 3,333 P535-43 5/6 2895.3.30 3,333 P535-43 6/6 219,843 ( (/ ) ) 1 94.4.4 15,000 ATM P621 2 94.4.5 6,894 P621 3 94.4.9 4,000 P621 4 94.7.15 3,000 ATM P621 5 94.7.15 2,000 ATM P621 6 94.7.15 2,000 ATM P621 7 94.11.2 1,697 P621 34,591 MASTER CARD0000000000000000 ( (/ ) ) 1 94.4.5 30,000 P58J380 2 94.4.8 10,000 ATM P58J380 3 94.4.8 20,000 ATM P58J380 4 94.7.29 3,000 ATM P58J380 5 94.9.18 1,000 ATM P58J380 6 94.11.23 1,000 ATM P58J380 7 94.11.23 2,000 ATM P58J380 8 94.12.9 2,000 ATM P58J380 69,000 VISA ( (/ ) ) 1 94.10.14 1,000 P512-21 2 94.10.14 98,000 P512-21 3 94.10.26 1,060 P512-21 4 94.10.26 1,130 P512-21 5 94.11.2 960 P512-21 6 94.11.2 7,852 P512-21 7 95.2.6 89 4,200 P512-21 114,202 AVISA0000000000000000 B0000000000000000 ( (/ ) ) 1 94.8.21 1,000 ATM A(J4) 2 94.8.21 1,000 ATM A(J4) 3 94.11.17 1,000 A(J4) 4 94.11.17 3,000 A(J4) 5 95.1.29 884 A(J4) 6 95.2.2 849 A(J4) 7 94.3.3 7,000 ATM B(J4) 8 94.3.3 2,0000 ATM B(J4) 9 94.3.4 2,0000 ATM B(J4) 54,733 VISA0000000000000000 ( (/ ) ) 1 94.2.4 1,150 P558-70 1/12 2 94.2.3 450 P558-70 3 94.2.3 13,170 P558-70 4 94.2.6 31,100 P558-70 5 94.2.8 20,000 ATM P558-70 6 94.2.8 20,000 ATM P558-70 7 94.2.13 4,550 P558-70 8 94.2.15 20,000 ATM P558-70 9 94.2.15 20,000 ATM P558-70 1094.2.4 1,150 P558-70 2/12 1194.4.12 1,150 P558-70 3/12 1294.4.13 10,000 ATM P558-70 1394.5.12 1,150 P558-70 4/12 1494.6.12 1,150 P558-70 5/12 1594.7.8 8,000 ATM P558-70 1694.7.12 1,150 P558-70 6/12 1794.8.12 1,150 P558-70 7/12 1894.8.18 630 P558-70 1994.8.18 8,084 P558-70 2094.9.12 1,150 P558-70 8/12 2194.10.6 20,000 ATM P558-70 2294.10.6 20,000 ATM P558-70 2394.10.6 10,000 ATM P558-70 2494.10.11 2,000 ATM P558-70 2594.10.12 2,358 P558-70 1/3 2694.10.12 3,255 P558-70 1/3 2794.10.12 3,366 P558-70 1/3 2894.10.12 1,150 P558-70 9/12 2994.10.13 6,000 P558-70 3094.10.13 3,387 P558-70 3194.10.13 3,904 P558-70 3294.10.13 4,392 P558-70 3394.10.13 4,680 P558-70 3494.10.13 1,568 P558-70 3594.10.14 20,000 P558-70 3694.10.14 15,060 P558-70 3794.10.19 590 P558-70 3894.10.20 3,127 P558-70 3994.11.3 15,000 ATM P558-70 4094.11.12 1,150 P558-70 10/12 4194.11.12 2,358 P558-70 2/3 4294.11.12 3,255 P558-70 2/3 4394.11.12 3,366 P558-70 2/3 4494.11.30 2,000 ATM P558-70 4594.11.3011,000 ATM P558-70 4694.12.12 1,150 P558-70 11/12 4794.12.12 2,358 P558-70 3/3 4894.12.12 3,255 P558-70 3/3 4994.12.12 3,366 P558-70 3/3 5095.1.12 1,150 P558-70 12/12 5195.1.19 11,000 ATM P558-70 350,429 VISA ( (/ ) ) 1 94.9.30 8,500 P522-31 2 94.9.30 140,000 P522-31 3 94.10.20 9,820 P522-31 4 94.11.9 3,670 P522-31 5 94.11.9 592 P522-31 6 95.2.6 89 8,250 P522-31 170,832 A 0000000000000000 B 0000000000000000 C 0000000000000000 ( (/ ) ) 1 94.2.1 LE STYLE 1,980 A(J4) 2 94.2.1 20,000 ATM A(J4) 3 94.2.1 20,000 ATM A(J4) 4 94.2.1 20,000 ATM A(J4) 5 94.2.1 20,000 ATM A(J4) 6 94.2.1 10,000 ATM A(J4) 7 94.2.5 2,884 A(J4) 8 94.2.5 3,996 A(J4) 9 94.2.5 6,310 A(J4) 1094.2.5 300 A(J4) 1194.2.5 800 A(J4) 1294.2.9 1/6 510 A(J4) 1394.2.9 2/6 510 A(J4) 1494.2.9 3/6 510 A(J4) 1594.2.9 4/6 510 A(J4) 1694.2.9 6/6 510 A(J4) 17 94.8.6 10,000 ATM B(J4) 1894.9.21 2,000 ATM C(J4) 1994.10.5 8,800 ATM C(J4) 2094.10.5 645 C(J4) 2194.11.1 1,000 ATM B(J4) 2294.11.2 6,360 B(J4) 2394.11.2 3,888 B(J4) 141,513