lawpalyer logo
in判決書

智慧財產及商業法院100年度民專上易字第10號

關鍵資訊

  • 裁判案由
    侵害專利權有關財產權爭議
  • 案件類型
    智財
  • 審判法院
    智慧財產及商業法院
  • 裁判日期
    100 年 08 月 25 日

  • 當事人
    歐陽偉家佳樂企業有限公司

10010         100 1 2799195 100 8 4 956 9 LED I309729 985 11115 6 8 7 1 9912231 調3,127,330 202006014503.67,530,706 200610035815.9991 11LED5W09 LED TRADE CHANNEL INTERNATIONAL L.L.C 使1,000 841 851 1 30852 20853 3 305% 1923Hunter2 調4 HunterF() 2F 2004Chapman [0045][0047]調調F 2F0~1FHunter81Hunter調Hunter HunterChapman 1F2F1F~ 使2F鹿0F~ 6 1 7 4 1F2F0 1F鹿0F~2F 1F0~2F Chapman 1F2F調鹿Chapman 1Facross the range of focus調S 1F1Fthroughoutthe entire range of focus 1FLED 使 Hunter1F 2 5 4 Hunter1F0F~2F 3.2. 4使HunterLED Hunter192381Chapman2004 Hunter1F2F 0F~2F Chpman 3 2 Hunter>0F~0F~2F Hunter0 使0F~2F 1 2 Hunter30Hunter30Hunter 使Hunter使Chapman LED 60使LED 使調 1F2F調1F0F2F調調使 - Problem-Solution Approach (Could-Would Approach)EPO - Problem-Solution Approach Could- Would Approach)Could Would Prior Art C-IV11.7.3EPO Could-Would Approachcould would can will LED LED LED 調使使使使LED Hunter調4 Hunter調 使3.2.1 300F1F~2F 300~0~2F200010使HunterChapman 1F1F~2F LED 1~4 7 98/5/11 調調981125991 119 35% 貿 30 LED 200610035815.9 20106 1198157 1 7 使 貿350 9 499 1,341 30TRADE CHANNEL INTERNATIONAL L.L.C 7 20 7980 1309729 LED 985 11115 6 8 80 1 5 7 LED LED ; LED 調使使使 7 1 1.LED LED 使LED LED LED LED LED LED LED LED 2.1 LED LED LED 3.1 LED 4.1 LED 5.1 LED 6.1 LED 使 7.1 LED LED 0mm 32mm 1 20049 30US2004/0190299A1Flashlight(LED) LED(50) (14)LED S 98 157 2-1 2 19231218US1,478,282 Flashlight(11)(12)使98157 3 1 2 956 9 1 2 1 1 1 1.1 3 (20)(90)4 LED(50) (90)(20)LED(50) (14)(16)(14)LED(50) S 使LED 1 1 LED LED LED 使LED LED 2.2 2 4 5 (11) (12)(6) 9 10使沿(slidingly rotate)(6) (12)(11)使0F~1F 1F1F~2F 6 1 2 0F~1F 1F~2F 2 1 LED LED LED LED LED LED 3.LED 使1 2 1 1 2 1 4.2 4 2 2 24fourthto use a short focal length lens 4 2 (slidingly rotate)(6) 調(12)(11) 4 (12) (11)1F~2F 2 2 4 調F 6 1 2 調(slidingly rotate)調0F~2F 21 調 1 2 2 4 5.2 (slidingly rotate)(6) (12)(11)使0F~2F 2 2F(12) (11)2 1 2 使2 Road MapLED LED 使LED 1 LED 2 1 LED 調LED 6.1 2 LED 2 360 ° 使1 使LED 60° 使LED 2 61使穿使使2 1 3 0048LED 使LED 607080901 1 2 1 2 2 2 1 LED LED LED LED 1 2 1 2 1 2 2 1 2 3 3 1 2 1 3 2 3 1 2 1 3 1 2 1 2 3 4 4 1 3 2 (6)(1) (12)4 1 2 1 4 3 124 1 2 5 5 1 2 1 [0039](20)(78) (16) 1 5 1 2 1 5 1 1 2 5 1 2 7 7 1 LED 0 32mm0 2F使2 0F2F1 [0035]8 16101412mm1 2 LED 1 32mm0 2F使1 2 7 9912231 1 1.LED LED 使LED LED LED LED LED LED LED LED 使LED 1 2 1 1.1 3 (20)(90)4 LED(50) (90)(20)LED(50) (14)(16)(14)LED(50) S 使LED 1 1 LED LED LED 使LED LED 2.2 2 4 5 (11)(12)(6) (slidingly rotate)(6) (12) (11) 使 0F~1F 1F1F~2F 6 1 2 0F~1F 1F~2F 2 4 1F~2F 2 1 2 2 1 LED LED LED LED LED LED 使LED 3.2 61使穿使使2 1 3 0048LED 使LED 60708090- could-would not simply could, but would 使1 3 4.LED 使1 2 1 1 2 1 224 162 1 449 1 78         100    8     25                 100    8     30