lawpalyer logo
in判決書

臺灣高等法院 臺中分院98年度金上更㈠字第1號

關鍵資訊

  • 裁判案由
    損害賠償
  • 案件類型
    民事
  • 審判法院
    臺灣高等法院 臺中分院
  • 裁判日期
    99 年 09 月 15 日

    981                                                      2                  () 25   () 23                3             33                                     164       164    40                            4                                                 1          12810          4    2                      3       811F          962       2       2          702    2       2                                                                 373                   6                   31                2    73    5          51       193             2                                         姿                      412         ()    125                                              93730 91334 99825 89229 561 8 16918716198526981 161 386 386 2223140 221133149 884592 調86滿871 12125290731836193485420 8710308787102987930 8687使88116 882220142 1841881852328 892295 892 295 87787887888 2滿113,211,9009,352,6503,859,250675,0005014,5004,534,250282,4907,100275,390 1,251,838 557,830694,0085,503,6485%2,591,3008,094,948 99262,366,400 718,1001,648,300256,5001914,5001,904,80089229987315%896,8432,801,643 8612242,135,790 1,608,080527,71088229987315 8,032,6686122499268710314.591 9926120,858 334,700 使 873 143 873 87102 2018822 871030882244714479926 使 12848150128 2232 87232 87 3203 8787退8787103089229 5 The Fraud on the MarketTheory 20西193410b Rule 10b-520西1988Basic,Inc.v.Levinsonnoise trading 使203 88238823reliance 8823882388244.59 調8612529731836 193485420 8687930 88245199289218調9356調8838321861898824516783307357 20912695111 868720912620202395111 20201 36 191208 20232 23223 2 20260 871030873 1851 873 調3620220201193410b 1988Basic,Inc.v.Levinson203 1571202161 87103088238710308823871030882 2 88121 88121 88 11688118881161 2987103088116 8823873 88 23 871030 使157 90908824882 3 88118 1 5.3400013.46.561450.0898124 0981002589998509910016895181186207 203 892 29 4504491385124637978852851 99 9 15 150 2020 466112 99 9 16 1 88.2.2 5.0 0000 00.40% 6.56% 1450.08 1450.00 0000 0 88.1.00 0 0000 00.43% 8.08% 11067.00 00000.00 00000 3 88.1.30 6.00 000000 00.37% 8.61% 206148.00 000000.00 000000 4 88.1.29 6.0 00000 00.38% 7.07% 46414.40 88.1.29 6.0 0000 00.45% 7.07% 6173.52 88.1.29 6.0 0000 00.38% 7.07% 1450.15 88.1.30 6.00 00000 00.72% 8.61% 44890.00 00000.00 00000 0 88.1.29 6.0 0000 00.38% 7.07% 4350.45 4350.00 0000 0 88.1.29 6.0 00000 00.38% 7.07% 21752.25 88.2.2 5.0 00000 00.40% 6.56% 19213.00 00000.00 00000 0 88.1.28 7.0 0000 00.35% 8.08% 1936.17 88.2.1 6.00 0000 00.37% 7.69% 1087.32 3023.00 0000 0 88.1.00 0 0000 00.43% 8.08% 5533.50 5533.00 0000 0 88.1.28 7.0 0000 00.25% 8.08% 4056.48 88.1.28 7.0 0000 00.35% 8.08% 5808.51 9864.00 0000 00 88.1.28 6.00 0000 00.96% 8.08% 8993.30 8993.00 0000 00 88.1.00 0 00000 00.43% 8.08% 18445.00 00000.00 00000 12 88.1.28 6.00 00000 00.96% 8.08% 17986.60 88.1.30 6.0 00000 00.75% 8.61% 9845.40 88.2.1 5.00 00000 00.76% 7.69% 6254.00 00000.00 00000 00 88.1.28 6.00 0000 00.96% 8.08% 8993.30 88.1.29 6.0 00000 00.38% 7.07% 14501.00 00000.00 00000 00 () 88.1.28 6.00 0000 00.96% 8.08% 3597.32 15 () 3597.00 0000 00 88.1.28 7.0 0000 00.35% 8.08% 7744.68 7744.00 0000 00 88.1.29 6.0 00000 00.38% 7.07% 14501.00 00000.00 00000 00 88.2.1 5.00 0000 00.76% 7.69% 1250.91 1250.00 0000 00 88.2.2 5.0 00000 00.40% 6.56% 7250.40 7250.00 0000 00 88.1.30 6.0 00000 00.75% 8.61% 19690.00 00000.00 00000 00 88.1.29 6.00 0000 00.99% 7.07% 1775.52 1775.00 0000 00 88.1.30 6.0 000000 00.75% 8.61% 98454.00 88.2.1 5.0 000000 00.47% 7.69% 67146.00 000000.00 000000.00 23 88.1.28 6.00 0000 00.96% 8.08% 8993.30 88.1.00 0 0000 00.43% 8.08% 5533.50 88.1.28 7.0 0000 00.35% 8.08% 3872.34 88.1.29 6.0 00000 00.38% 7.07% 14501.50 88.1.30 6.00 00000 00.13% 8.61% 9389.60 88.2.1 5.00 00000 00.76% 7.69% 6254.00 00000.00 00000 00 87.11.4 13.0 0000 00.25% 34.22% 21780.40 87.12.3 13.0 0000 00.25% 26.23% 38099.04 87.12.4 13.0 0000 00.25% 26.40% 27098.00 00000.00 00000 25 88.1.30 6.0 0000 00.38% 8.61% 1350.05 88.2.1 5.00 0000 00.76% 7.69% 1876.37 3226.00 0000 00 88.1.29 6.0 0000 00.38% 7.03% 7263.75 7263.00 0000 00 88.2.2 5.00 00000 00.21% 6.56% 4092.75 88.2.2 5.0 00000 00.40% 6.56% 7250.00 00000.00 00000 00 87.10.31 13.0 0000 00.74% 37.69% 20044.50 87.11.2 13.0 0000 00.25% 37.14% 15835.84 87.11.23 13.0 0000 00.50% 29.53% 5064.89 88.1.00 00 0000 00.69% 13.12% 26816.40 88.1.22 9.0 0000 00.11% 9.83% 7411.52 88.1.25 8.0 0000 00.63% 6.80% 20552.28 88.1.00 0 0000 00.63% 7.38% 2820.00 88.1.29 6.0 0000 00.38% 7.07% 5800.60 88.2.1 6.00 00000 00.13% 7.69% 15913.92 88.2.2 5.0 0000 00.40% 6.56% 1450.00 000000.00 000000 00 87.12.16 13.0 0000 00.25% 24.23% 28573.60 88.1.30 6.00 0000 00.13% 8.61% 4694.00 00000.00 00000 00 () 88.1.00 00 0000 00.69% 13.12% 6704.10 88.1.28 7.00 00000 00.80% 8.08% 43603.56 88.1.00 0 0000 00.43% 8.08% 5533.00 00000.00 00000 00 87.12.10 13.0 00000 00.25% 24.81% 56358.40 88.1.00 00 0000 00.69% 13.12% 33520.50 88.1.25 8.0 0000 00.63% 6.80% 6850.76 88.2.2 5.0 00000 00.00% 6.56% 4557.00 000000.00 000000 00 88.1.28 6.00 0000 00.96% 8.08% 3597.32 88.2.2 5.0 0000 00.40% 6.56% 725.04 4322.00 0000 00 88.1.28 6.00 0000 00.96% 8.08% 3597.32 3597.00 0000 00 88.1.29 6.0 00000 00.39% 7.07% 14508.00 00000.00 00000 35 () 88.1.28 7.00 0000 00.89% 8.08% 9450.53 36 () 37 () 38 () 39 () 40 () 9450.00 0000 00 88.1.28 6.00 0000 00.96% 8.08% 3597.32 3597.00 0000 00 88.1.28 6.00 0000 00.96% 8.08% 14389.00 00000.00 00000 43 88.1.28 7.00 00000 00.39% 8.08% 22580.00 00000.00 00000 00 0 87.12.19 13.0 0000 00.75% 18.29% 57236.00 00000.00 00000 00 88.2.1 6.00 00000 00.56% 7.69% 11793.00 00000.00 00000 00 88.1.28 7.00 00000 00.39% 8.08% 22580.00 00000.00 00000 47 88.1.22 9.0 0000 00.11% 9.83% 3705.76 88.2.2 5.0 0000 00.40% 6.56% 362.52 4068.00 0000 00 88.2.2 5.0 0000 00.40% 6.56% 725.04 725.00 000 00 88.2.2 5.0 00000 00.40% 6.56% 3625.20 3625.00 0000 00 87.11.19 13.0 0000 00.25% 28.58% 15369.36 88.2.2 5.0 0000 00.40% 6.56% 725.00 00000.00 00000 00 88.1.28 6.00 0000 00.96% 8.08% 1798.66 1798.00 0000 00 88.2.1 5.0 00000 00.47% 7.69% 11414.00 00000.00 00000 00 88.1.28 6.00 0000 00.96% 8.08% 3597.32 3597.00 0000 00 88.2.2 5.0 0000 00.00% 6.56% 455.76 455.00 000 00 () 88.1.28 6.00 00000 00.96% 8.08% 17986.00 00000.00 00000 00 88.1.00 0 00000 00.43% 8.08% 18445.00 00000.00 00000 57 88.1.30 6.0 0000 00.38% 8.61% 2700.10 88.2.1 6.00 0000 00.13% 7.69% 1989.24 4689.00 0000 00 88.1.29 7.0 0000 00.35% 7.03% 2010.72 2010.00 0000 00 88.1.28 6.00 0000 00.96% 8.08% 3597.32 3597.00 0000 00 87.11.20 13.0 00000 00.74% 30.38% 100353.60 88.1.22 9.0 00000 00.11% 9.83% 37057.60 88.1.28 7.0 00000 00.97% 8.08% 44237.00 000000.00 000000 00 88.1.29 6.0 00000 00.38% 7.07% 14501.50 88.2.1 5.0 00000 00.86% 7.69% 7638.60 88.2.2 5.0 00000 00.40% 6.56% 3625.00 00000.00 00000 00 88.1.28 6.00 00000 00.96% 8.08% 17986.00 00000.00 00000 00 () 88.1.28 6.00 0000 00.96% 8.08% 3597.32 64 () 88.1.29 6.0 0000 00.38% 7.07% 2900.30 65 () 88.2.2 5.0 0000 00.40% 6.56% 725.04 66 () 67 () 7222.00 0000 00 88.1.30 6.00 00000 00.72% 8.61% 24269.00 00000.00 00000 00 () 88.1.28 6.00 0000 00.96% 8.08% 1798.66 70 () 71 () 1798.00 0000 00 87.12.30 13.0 0000 00.96% 12.48% 13749.76 87.12.31 13.0 0000 00.96% 11.31% 21084.45 88.2.2 5.00 0000 00.21% 6.56% 2046.00 00000.00 00000 00 () 88.2.2 5.0 0000 00.40% 6.56% 362.52 362.00 000 00 88.1.29 6.0 00000 00.38% 7.07% 14501.50 88.1.30 6.0 00000 00.75% 8.61% 9845.40 88.2.1 5.00 00000 00.76% 7.69% 6254.55 88.2.2 5.0 00000 00.40% 6.56% 3625.00 00000.00 00000 00 87.12.18 13.00 0000 00.88% 20.89% 6051.16 6051.00 0000 00 88.1.28 6.00 0000 00.96% 8.08% 1798.66 1798.00 0000 00 88.1.28 6.00 0000 00.96% 8.08% 16187.00 00000.00 00000 00 88.1.28 6.00 00000 00.96% 8.08% 35973.20 88.2.2 5.0 00000 00.40% 6.56% 10875.00 00000.00 00000 00 () 88.1.00 0 00000 00.43% 8.08% 18445.00 80 () 81 () 82 () 18445.00 00000 83 88.1.28 6.00 00000 00.96% 8.08% 17986.00 00000.00 00000 00 88.2.2 5.0 0000 00.40% 6.56% 362.52 362.00 000 00 87.11.13 13.00 000 00.32% 29.13% 811.04 811.00 000 00 88.1.30 6.0 0000 00.38% 8.61% 8100.30 88.2.2 5.0 0000 00.00% 6.56% 911.52 9011.00 0000 00 88.1.28 6.00 0000 00.96% 8.08% 1798.66 1798.00 0000 00 88.2.2 5.0 0000 00.40% 6.56% 362.52 362.00 000 00 88.1.28 6.00 0000 00.96% 8.08% 1798.66 1798.00 0000 00 88.1.27 7.00 0000 00.39% 9.07% 4368.68 88.1.28 6.00 00000 00.96% 8.08% 25181.24 88.1.29 6.0 00000 00.38% 7.07% 29003.00 88.2.1 5.0 0000 00.86% 7.69% 3819.00 00000.00 00000 00 88.1.28 6.00 00000 00.96% 8.08% 35973.00 00000.00 00000 92 88.1.28 7.00 0000 00.39% 8.08% 2258.10 2258.00 0000 00 88.1.28 6.00 00000 00.96% 8.08% 35973.20 88.1.29 6.0 0000 00.38% 7.07% 2900.00 00000.00 00000 00 88.1.28 6.00 0000 00.96% 8.08% 3597.32 88.1.29 6.0 0000 00.38% 7.07% 2900.30 6497.00 0000 00 88.2.2 5.0 0000 00.00% 6.56% 1367.28 1367.00 0000 00 87.12.21 13.0 0000 00.50% 29.13% 5119.69 5119.00 0000 00 88.2.2 5.0 00000 00.00% 6.56% 45120.00 00000.00 00000 98 88.1.29 6.0 0000 00.38% 7.07% 1450.15 1450.00 0000 00 88.1.00 0 00000 00.43% 8.08% 18445.00 00000.00 00000 000 87.11.3 13.0 0000 00.25% 35.84% 4135.76 4135.00 0000 000 88.1.27 7.00 0000 00.39% 9.07% 2184.34 88.1.29 6.0 0000 00.38% 7.07% 1450.15 88.1.30 6.00 0000 00.13% 8.61% 1877.92 5512.00 0000 000 () 88.1.28 6.00 00000 00.96% 8.08% 17986.60 103 () 88.1.30 6.00 00000 00.84% 8.61% 13048.35 104 () 31034.00 00000 000 88.1.28 6.00 0000 00.96% 8.08% 1798.66 88.1.30 6.00 0000 00.13% 8.61% 938.96 2737.00 0000 000 88.1.28 7.00 00000 00.39% 8.08% 22580.95 88.1.29 6.0 0000 00.38% 7.07% 7250.75 88.1.30 6.0 0000 00.38% 8.61% 6750.00 00000.00 00000 000 88.1.28 6.00 0000 00.96% 8.08% 8993.30 8993.00 0000 000 88.2.1 5.00 0000 00.76% 7.69% 3127.28 88.2.2 5.0 0000 00.40% 6.56% 362.52 3489.00 0000 000 88.2.1 5.00 0000 00.76% 7.69% 1876.37 88.2.2 5.0 0000 00.40% 6.56% 725.04 2601.00 0000 000 88.1.28 7.00 0000 00.89% 8.08% 1890.11 88.1.00 0 0000 00.43% 8.08% 1844.50 3734.00 0000 000 88.1.28 6.00 0000 00.96% 8.08% 3597.32 88.2.2 5.0 0000 00.40% 6.56% 725.04 4322.00 0000 000 88.1.30 6.0 0000 00.76% 8.61% 4925.75 4925.00 0000 000 88.1.28 6.00 00000 00.96% 8.08% 35973.20 88.2.2 5.0 00000 00.40% 6.56% 7250.00 00000.00 00000 000 87.11.20 13.00 00000 00.37% 30.38% 49126.35 87.11.27 13.00 00000 00.62% 26.97% 54518.75 87.12.1 13.00 00000 00.62% 25.49% 56553.00 000000.00 000000 000 88.1.00 00 0000 00.69% 13.12% 40224.00 00000.00 00000 000 88.1.28 6.00 0000 00.96% 8.08% 3597.32 3597.00 0000 000 88.1.29 6.0 0000 00.38% 7.07% 2900.30 2900.00 0000 000 88.1.28 7.0 00000 00.97% 8.08% 22118.00 00000.00 00000 000 88.1.28 6.0 00000 00.38% 8.08% 27690.00 88.1.29 6.0 0000 00.38% 7.07% 7250.75 88.1.29 6.0 00000 00.38% 7.07% 14501.00 00000.00 00000 000 88.1.22 9.0 00000 00.11% 9.83% 37057.00 00000.00 00000 000 88.1.28 7.0 0000 00.97% 8.08% 11059.30 88.1.30 6.00 0000 00.13% 8.61% 4694.00 00000.00 00000 000 88.1.28 8.0 00000 00.63% 6.80% 51380.70 88.1.30 6.0 00000 00.75% 8.61% 9845.00 00000.00 00000 000 88.1.28 6.00 00000 00.96% 8.08% 35973.00 00000.00 00000 000 88.1.30 6.0 0000 00.38% 8.61% 2700.10 2700.00 0000 000 88.2.0 0 0000 00.50% 7.69% 2845.80 2845.00 0000 000 88.1.28 6.00 0000 00.96% 8.08% 8993.30 88.1.28 6.00 0000 00.96% 8.08% 8993.30 88.2.2 5.0 0000 00.40% 6.56% 1812.00 00000.00 00000 000 88.2.1 5.00 0000 00.76% 7.69% 3127.28 88.2.2 5.0 0000 00.40% 6.56% 725.04 3852.00 0000 000 88.1.28 7.00 00000 00.39% 8.08% 22580.00 00000.00 00000 000 88.1.30 6.00 00000 00.13% 8.61% 46948.00 00000.00 00000 130 88.1.28 7.00 00000 00.89% 8.08% 37802.00 00000.00 00000 000 88.2.2 5.0 0000 00.40% 6.56% 1812.60 1812.00 0000 000 88.1.28 6.00 0000 00.96% 8.08% 8993.30 88.2.2 5.0 0000 00.40% 6.56% 1812.00 00000.00 00000 000 88.1.29 6.0 00000 00.38% 7.07% 101510.00 000000.00 000000 000 88.1.30 6.00 00000 00.13% 8.61% 17840.00 00000.00 00000 000 88.1.28 6.00 00000 00.96% 8.08% 35973.00 00000.00 00000 000 88.1.7 12.00 0000 00.56% 9.96% 14141.40 88.1.28 6.00 0000 00.96% 8.08% 3597.32 88.1.29 6.0 0000 00.38% 7.07% 1450.15 88.1.30 6.0 0000 00.75% 8.61% 984.54 88.2.1 5.00 0000 00.76% 7.69% 625.00 00000.00 00000 000 88.2.1 5.00 00000 00.76% 7.69% 12509.00 00000.00 00000 000 87.12.16 13.00 00000 00.37% 24.23% 86281.65 87.12.18 13.0 00000 00.00% 20.89% 60898.50 88.1.8 13.00 00000 00.10% 12.57% 69076.95 88.1.25 8.0 00000 00.63% 6.80% 34253.80 88.1.28 7.00 00000 00.89% 8.08% 18901.00 000000.00 000000 000 88.1.28 6.00 00000 00.96% 8.08% 17986.00 00000.00 00000 000 88.2.2 5.0 0000 00.40% 6.56% 1087.56 1087.00 0000 000 88.2.2 5.00 0000 00.21% 6.56% 1227.83 1227.00 0000 000 88.2.2 5.0 0000 00.00% 6.56% 455.76 455.00 000 000 88.1.30 6.0 0000 00.75% 8.61% 4922.70 88.2.1 6.00 00000 00.13% 7.69% 9946.20 88.2.1 5.0 0000 00.86% 7.69% 3819.30 88.2.2 5.0 0000 00.40% 6.56% 1812.60 88.2.2 5.0 00000 00.00% 6.56% 4557.00 00000.00 00000 000 88.1.30 6.00 0000 00.13% 8.61% 938.96 88.2.1 5.00 0000 00.76% 7.69% 625.46 88.2.1 5.0 0000 00.40% 7.69% 302.63 1867.00 0000 000 88.2.2 5.0 00000 00.40% 6.56% 5437.80 5438.00 0000 000 88.1.28 6.00 0000 00.96% 8.08% 1798.66 1798.00 0000 000 () 87.12.31 13.0 00000 00.96% 11.31% 140563.00 88.1.00 0 00000 00.43% 8.08% 18445.00 000000.00 000000 000 88.1.28 6.00 0000 00.96% 8.08% 3597.32 3597.00 0000 000 87.11.5 13.0 0000 00.00% 33.33% 22052.00 00000.00 00000 000 88.1.28 6.00 00000 00.96% 8.08% 21583.00 00000.00 00000 000 () 88.1.29 6.0 0000 00.38% 7.03% 1452.75 152 () 0.00 153 () 0.00 1452.00 0000 000 88.1.29 6.0 000000 00.38% 7.03% 290550.00 000000.00 000000 155 88.1.28 6.00 00000 00.96% 8.08% 53959.80 88.1.29 6.0 00000 00.38% 7.03% 29055.00 88.2.1 5.00 00000 00.76% 7.69% 12509.00 00000.00 00000 000 88.2.1 5.00 0000 00.76% 7.69% 3127.28 3127.00 0000 000 88.2.2 5.0 00000 00.00% 6.56% 4557.60 88.2.2 5.0 00000 00.40% 6.56% 10875.00 00000.00 00000 000 88.1.28 6.00 0000 00.96% 8.08% 8993.30 8993.00 0000 000 88.1.29 6.0 00000 00.38% 7.03% 139464.00 000000.00 000000 000 88.1.28 6.00 0000 00.96% 8.08% 1798.66 1798.00 0000 000 88.1.28 6.00 00000 00.96% 8.08% 17986.00 00000.00 00000 000 88.1.28 6.00 0000 00.96% 8.08% 3597.32 88.1.30 6.00 0000 00.25% 8.61% 1102.50 4699.00 0000 000 () 88.1.28 7.00 00000 00.89% 8.08% 94505.25 164 () 0.00 00000.00 00000 000 88.1.28 7.0 0000 00.35% 8.08% 9680.85 88.2.2 5.0 0000 00.40% 6.56% 1812.00 00000.00 00000 000 88.1.28 6.00 00000 00.96% 8.08% 17986.60 88.1.30 6.0 00000 00.75% 8.61% 9845.40 88.2.1 5.0 00000 00.47% 7.69% 6714.60 88.2.1 5.00 0000 00.76% 7.69% 3127.00 00000.00 00000 000 87.11.5 13.00 00000 00.13% 33.33% 44444.00 87.11.17 13.0 0000 00.74% 28.49% 26392.00 00000.00 00000 000 87.11.24 13.0 00000 00.50% 29.38% 76281.00 00000.00 00000 000 87.11.25 13.00 0000 00.13% 26.79% 10661.00 00000.00 00000 000 88.1.29 6.0 0000 00.38% 7.03% 1452.75 1452.00 0000 000 87.11.18 13.0 00000 00.50% 28.22% 157330.00 000000.00 000000 000 88.1.28 6.00 0000 00.96% 8.08% 1798.66 88.1.28 7.0 0000 00.35% 8.08% 1936.17 88.1.29 6.0 0000 00.38% 7.03% 2905.50 99.1.30 6.0 0000 00.75% 8.61% 984.54 7624.00 0000 000 88.1.30 6.0 0000 00.75% 8.61% 1969.08 1969.00 0000 000 88.1.28 6.00 0000 00.96% 8.08% 1798.66 88.1.30 6.00 0000 00.37% 8.61% 2061.48 88.2.2 5.0 0000 00.00% 6.56% 1367.28 5227.00 0000 000 88.1.26 6.00 0000 00.96% 7.38% 1847.31 88.2.2 5.0 0000 00.40% 6.56% 362.52 2209.00 0000 000 88.1.30 6.00 00000 00.13% 8.61% 9389.60 88.2.1 5.00 00000 00.76% 7.69% 6254.00 00000.00 00000 000 88.1.29 6.0 00000 00.38% 7.07% 20302.00 00000.00 00000 000 88.1.28 6.00 00000 00.96% 8.08% 172671.36 88.1.28 7.00 00000 00.89% 8.08% 128527.14 88.2.1 5.00 000000 00.76% 7.69% 93818.00 000000.00 000000 000 88.2.1 5.00 0000 00.76% 7.69% 625.46 625.46 625 180 () 88.1.28 6.00 0000 00.96% 8.08% 1798.66 1798.66 1799