資料來源：司法院裁判書系統
臺灣雲林地方法院刑事判決
114年度訴字第273號
- 公訴人
- 臺灣雲林地方檢察署檢察官
- 被告
- 許佳琪
- 選任辯護人
- 張蓁騏律師
上列被告因違反個人資料保護法案件，經檢察官提起公訴（114年度調偵字第15號），本院判決如下：
主文
許佳琪犯個人資料保護法第四十一條之非公務機關非法處理個人資料罪，處有期徒刑陸月，如易科罰金，以新臺幣壹仟元折算壹日。緩刑伍年，並應依附表一所示之金額、內容及方式向林芝柔給付賠償金。
事實
一、許佳琪自民國107年10月1日起至112年6月30日止，受僱於林芝柔為負責人之馥柔居家護理所（址設雲林縣○○鎮○○路0段000號2樓，已歇業），擔任負責紀錄、維護管理其護理對象之護理評估、護理措施、護理指導及諮詢、醫療輔助行為及護理處置方式之護理師，並掌有馥柔居家護理所申辦之uCare長照資訊系統之帳號「didi0825」、密碼。詎許佳琪聽聞林芝柔預計於112年6月30日結束馥柔居家護理所之經營，明知長照服務對象居家護理「需求摘要」之「措施」、「評估紀錄」屬於個人資料保護法第2條第1款所稱個人資料，非公務機關對個人資料之處理，應於蒐集之特定目的必要範圍內為之，竟意圖損害林芝柔及馥柔居家護理所之利益，基於非法處理他人個人資料以及無故刪除他人電腦電磁紀錄之接續犯意，自112年6月15日13時8分許起至112年6月27日10時44分許止，以帳號「didi0825」及不詳密碼，進入馥柔居家護理所之長照資訊系統電腦資料庫，未得林芝柔許可或授權，無故刪除附表二所示馥柔居家護理所之服務對象居家護理「需求摘要」之「措施」、「評估紀錄」等電磁紀錄，而以此方式非法處理馥柔居家護理所之服務對象之個人資料，致生損害於林芝柔及馥柔居家護理所。嗣林芝柔發現如附表二所示之電磁紀錄遭到刪除，經諾亞克公司提供如附表二所示遭刪除之紀錄，林芝柔訴請檢察官究辦，始循線查悉上情。
二、案經林芝柔告訴暨臺灣雲林地方檢察署檢察官偵查起訴。
理由
壹、程序部分：
一、按被告以外之人於審判外之陳述，雖不符刑事訴訟法第159條之1至第159條之4之規定，而經當事人於審判程序同意作為證據，法院審酌該言詞陳述或書面陳述作成時之情況，認為適當者，亦得為證據，刑事訴訟法第159條之5第1項定有明文。經查，本判決下列所引用被告以外之人於審判外之陳述，檢察官、被告許佳琪及辯護人於本院審理中均表示同意作為證據等語（本院卷一第45至47、114、179至180、183頁），本院審酌上開證據資料製作時之情況，尚無違法不當及證明力明顯過低之瑕疵，以之作為證據應屬適當，揆諸前開規定，認前揭證據資料有證據能力。
二、本判決所引用之非供述證據，本院審酌該證據與本件待證事實均具有關連性，且無證據證明係實施刑事訴訟程序之公務員違背法定程序所取得，依同法第158條之4之反面解釋，自得作為證據使用。
貳、認定犯罪事實所憑之證據及理由：
一、被告就上開犯罪事實於審判中（本院卷ㄧ第192頁）坦承不諱，並有附表四「證據出處」欄所示證據在卷可佐，足以擔保被告之自白與事實相符，可以採信。
二、綜上所述，本案事證明確，被告犯行堪以認定，應依法論科。
參、論罪科刑之理由：
一、核被告所為，係犯刑法第359條無故刪除他人電腦之電磁紀錄罪、個人資料保護法第19條第1項、第41條之非公務機關非法處理個人資料罪。
二、被告基於單一犯意，於密接接近之時間、接續無故刪除附表二所示之電磁紀錄，侵害同一法益，各舉動之獨立性薄弱，依一般社會觀念，在時間差距上，難以強行分開，在刑法評價上，以視為數個舉動接續施行，合為包括一行為予以評價較為合理，應論以接續犯。
三、被告以一行為同時觸犯無故刪除他人電腦之電磁紀錄、非公務機關非法處理個人資料罪，為想像競合犯，應從一重之非法處理個人資料罪處斷。
四、爰以行為人之責任為基礎，審酌被告行為時身為護理師，無故刪除馥柔居家護理所之附表二所示之電腦電磁紀錄，而非法處理個人資料，破壞馥柔居家護理所對於該等電磁紀錄之支配、控制及完整使用，並影響馥柔居家護理所之經營運作及復業，所為實在不可取。復考量被告無刑事前科，有法院前案紀錄表供參，素行尚可，被告於審理時坦承犯行，已與告訴人林芝柔達成和解，有和解筆錄在卷可參，暨被告審理時自陳之教育程度、家庭經濟狀況等一切情狀，量處如主文所示之刑，並諭知易科罰金之折算標準。
五、被告未曾因故意犯罪而受有期徒刑以上刑之宣告等情，有法院前案紀錄表可參。被告因一時失慮，致罹刑案，於犯後終能坦承犯行。且參以在本院審理時，已與告訴人達成和解，獲告訴人諒解，足認被告經此偵審程序與論罪科刑教訓，應已知所警惕，而無再犯之虞，本院綜核上情，認被告所受上開宣告之刑，以暫不執行為適當，爰依刑法第74條第1項第1款規定宣告緩刑5年，以勵自新。又為保障告訴人之權益，被告已與告訴人達成和解，和解成立之金額、內容及給付方式如附表一所示，本院斟酌上開各項情狀後，認於被告緩刑期間課予其應依如附表一所示之金額、內容及給付方式向告訴人履行支付損害賠償之負擔，乃為適當，以收緩刑之功效，爰依刑法第74條第2項第3款規定，併諭知被告應依附表一所示內容支付告訴人賠償金。倘被告未遵循本院諭知之緩刑期間所定負擔而情節重大者，檢察官得依刑事訴訟法第476條及刑法第75條之1第1項第4款之規定，聲請撤銷本案緩刑之宣告，併予敘明。
肆、不另為無罪部分：
一、公訴意旨略以：被告意圖損害林芝柔及馥柔居家護理所之利益，基於非法處理他人個人資料以及無故刪除他人電腦電磁紀錄之接續犯意，自112年6月15日13時8分許起至112年6月27日10時44分許止，以帳號「didi0825」及不詳密碼，進入馥柔居家護理所之長照資訊系統電腦資料庫，未得林芝柔許可或授權，無故接續刪除㈠附表三所示資料之電磁紀錄、㈡（附表二以外）其餘全數護理對象之病歷及護理資料之電磁紀錄，致生損害於林芝柔及馥柔居家護理所。因認此部分同涉犯刑法第359條之無故刪除他人電腦之電磁紀錄罪嫌、個人資料保護法第19條第1項、第41條之非公務機關非法處理個人資料罪嫌等語。
二、按犯罪事實應依證據認定之，無證據不得認定犯罪事實；不能證明被告犯罪者，應諭知無罪之判決，刑事訴訟法第154條第2項、第301條第1項定有明文。刑事訴訟法第161條第1項規定：「檢察官就被告犯罪事實，應負舉證責任，並指出證明之方法。」是檢察官對於起訴之犯罪事實，應負提出證據及說服之實質舉證責任。再者，認定犯罪事實所憑之證據，雖不以直接證據為限，間接證據亦包括在內；然而無論直接或間接證據，其為訴訟上之證明，須於通常一般之人均不致有所懷疑，而得確信其為真實之程度者，始得據為有罪之認定，倘其證明尚未達到此一程度，而有合理之懷疑存在時，即無從為有罪之認定（最高法院76年度台上字第4986號判決意旨參照）。
三、公訴意旨認被告涉犯上開非法處理個人資料、無故刪除他人電腦電磁紀錄罪嫌，無非係以附表四所示證據，為其主要之論據。被告固坦承刪除附表三之電磁紀錄之事實，惟辯稱：沒有刪除全部護理對象之病歷及護理資料之電腦電磁紀錄等語（本院卷一第42至43頁）。
四、經查：
㈠起訴書記載被告「將資料庫內儲存之護理對象之病歷及護理資料『全數』刪除」，於114年6月17日準備程序時，檢察官表示：起訴的部分是刪除全部資料庫內儲存對象的病歷及護理資料（本院卷一第43頁）；於115年1月27日準備程序時，檢察官復表示：起訴被告刪除、非法處理的範圍如他卷第17至33頁所示（即附表二加上附表三）等語（本院卷一第112至113頁）。
㈡有關他卷第17至33頁所示遭刪除資料（即附表二加上附表三），經函詢諾亞克科技股份有限公司，該公司說明如下：
⒈附表二及附表三之「action」欄位，意義是指該筆所執行的資料庫動作，顯示「delete」即代表執行了一次「刪除（delete）」指令。
⒉「table_name」欄位係該次動作所影響的「資料表」名稱。附表二所示「hcevaluation30_measure」資料表、「hcevaluation30_evaluation」資料表、附表三所示「inpatientinfo」資料表，三種資料表均屬uCare居家護理子系統。
⒊「hcevaluation30_measure」係居家護理「需求摘要」表單之「措施」明細區塊，「移除」某一列措施後按儲存，系統刪除該一列措施明細（非整份病歷）。
⒋「hcevaluation30_evaluation」係居家護理「需求摘要」表單之「評估紀錄」明細區塊。「移除」某一列評估紀錄後儲存，系統刪除該一列評估紀錄明細。
⒌「inpatientinfo」係住民入住床位資料，此刪除係「住民結案」功能的正常流程之一。當承辦人員為個案辧理結案（例如post內含Qclosedate結案日期、Qreason結案原因、Qmemo結案說明，諸如「因6月底歇業、予轉介、予新護理師交接、予結案」），系統於結案時以DELETE FROM inpatientinfo WHERE patientID=<個案編號>釋出其床位。本表刪除「不等於」病歷或個資被清除。inpatientinfo僅記録「哪位住民住在哪張床、何時入住」之床位佔用對應。刪除此筆，僅代表該住民結案後釋放床位；其個案主檔、護理紀録、病歷、評估資料等並不在本表內，亦不因本筆刪除而消失。此刪除係住民結案流程釋放床位之正常動作，所刪除者僅為「床位佔用對應」，並非病歷或個案主檔。
⒍上述有諾亞克公司114年10月14日諾法字第11410001號函（本院卷一第75至81頁）、資料表所對應之系統表單及其刪除資料內容說明書（本院卷一第155至159頁）等在卷可佐。
㈢綜上：
⒈檢察官起訴被告刪除「全數」「資料庫內儲存之護理對象之病歷及護理資料」，僅有舉證證明附表二所示服務對象居家護理「需求摘要」之「措施」、「評估紀錄」等電腦電磁紀錄遭刪除，附表二以外，檢察官未舉證證明被告刪除其餘部分護理對象之病歷及護理資料，自無從遽認被告有何刪除其餘部分護理對象之病歷及護理資料之犯行。
⒉檢察官起訴被告刪除附表三部分，涉犯非法處理個人資料、無故刪除他人電腦電磁紀錄罪嫌，然據上述㈡、⒌諾亞克公司之說明，附表三所示表單之刪除係住民結案流程釋放床位之正常動作，所刪除者僅為「床位佔用對應」，並非病歷或個案主檔，本院認被告刪除此等住民入住床位資料之電磁紀錄，檢察官未舉證被告此部分刪除行為屬「無故」或已逾越處理個人資料應於特定目的之必要範圍，尚難逕認被告此部分所為構成刑法第359條之「無故」、個人資料保護法第41條第1項「逾越特定目的之必要範圍」，無從逕以刑法第359條之無故刪除他人電腦之電磁紀錄罪、個人資料保護法第41條之非公務機關非法處理個人資料罪嫌相繩。
五、被告被訴無故刪除㈠附表三所示資料之電磁紀錄、㈡（附表二以外）其餘全數護理對象之病歷及護理資料之電磁紀錄部分，涉犯刑法第359條之無故刪除他人電腦之電磁紀錄、個人資料保護法第41條之非公務機關非法處理個人資料罪嫌，尚屬不能證明，原應諭知無罪，然因公訴人認此部分如若成罪，應與前經本院認定有罪之無故刪除他人電腦之電磁紀錄、非法處理個人資料罪部分（附表二）具有接續犯之實質上一罪關係，爰不另為無罪之諭知。
據上論斷，應依刑事訴訟法第299條第1項前段，判決如主文。
本案經檢察官郭怡君提起公訴，檢察官曹瑞宏到庭執行職務。
以上正本與原本無異。
附表 / 起訴書（原樣呈現）
附錄本判決論罪科刑法條：
個人資料保護法第19條
非公務機關對個人資料之蒐集或處理，除第六條第一項所規定資
料外，應有特定目的，並符合下列情形之一者：
一、法律明文規定。
二、與當事人有契約或類似契約之關係，且已採取適當之安全措
施。
三、當事人自行公開或其他已合法公開之個人資料。
四、學術研究機構基於公共利益為統計或學術研究而有必要，且
資料經過提供者處理後或經蒐集者依其揭露方式無從識別特
定之當事人。
五、經當事人同意。
六、為增進公共利益所必要。
七、個人資料取自於一般可得之來源。但當事人對該資料之禁止
處理或利用，顯有更值得保護之重大利益者，不在此限。
八、對當事人權益無侵害。
蒐集或處理者知悉或經當事人通知依前項第七款但書規定禁止對
該資料之處理或利用時，應主動或依當事人之請求，刪除、停止
處理或利用該個人資料。
個人資料保護法第41條
意圖為自己或第三人不法之利益或損害他人之利益，而違反第六
條第一項、第十五條、第十六條、第十九條、第二十條第一項規
定，或中央目的事業主管機關依第二十一條限制國際傳輸之命令
或處分，足生損害於他人者，處五年以下有期徒刑，得併科新臺
幣一百萬元以下罰金。
中華民國刑法第359條
無故取得、刪除或變更他人電腦或其相關設備之電磁紀錄，致生
損害於公眾或他人者，處五年以下有期徒刑、拘役或科或併科六
十萬元以下罰金。
附表一：
編號 和解成立之金額、內容及給付方式（新臺幣） 備註及證據 1 被告許佳琪願意給付原告林芝柔新臺幣（下同）240,000元整。給付方式分期給付，共分60期，自115年8月5日起至120年7月5日止，按月於每月5日前各匯款4,000元予原告林芝柔設於臺灣中小企業銀行虎尾分行（帳號：00000000000、戶名：林芝柔）之帳戶內，如有一期不履行視為全部到期。 本院115年度附民字第776號和解筆錄之和解成立內容第一項（本院卷一第199頁）
附表二：
編號 id action table_name cmd execute_user_id created_at updated_at 1 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/15 13:08 2023/6/15 13:08 2 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/15 13:08 2023/6/15 13:08 3 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/15 13:08 2023/6/15 13:08 4 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/15 13:08 2023/6/15 13:08 5 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/15 16:17 2023/6/15 16:17 6 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/15 16:17 2023/6/15 16:17 7 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/15 16:17 2023/6/15 16:17 8 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/15 16:17 2023/6/15 16:17 9 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/15 16:59 2023/6/15 16:59 10 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/15 16:59 2023/6/15 16:59 11 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/15 16:59 2023/6/15 16:59 12 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/15 16:59 2023/6/15 16:59 13 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/15 17:21 2023/6/15 17:21 14 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/15 17:21 2023/6/15 17:21 15 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/15 17:21 2023/6/15 17:21 16 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/15 17:21 2023/6/15 17:21 17 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/15 18:01 2023/6/15 18:01 18 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/15 18:01 2023/6/15 18:01 19 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/15 18:01 2023/6/15 18:01 20 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/15 18:01 2023/6/15 18:01 21 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/15 18:36 2023/6/15 18:36 22 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/15 18:36 2023/6/15 18:36 23 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/15 18:36 2023/6/15 18:36 24 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/15 18:36 2023/6/15 18:36 25 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/16 12:11 2023/6/16 12:11 26 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/16 12:11 2023/6/16 12:11 27 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/16 12:11 2023/6/16 12:11 28 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/16 12:11 2023/6/16 12:11 29 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/16 12:59 2023/6/16 12:59 30 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/16 12:59 2023/6/16 12:59 31 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/16 12:59 2023/6/16 12:59 32 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/16 12:59 2023/6/16 12:59 33 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/16 14:55 2023/6/16 14:55 34 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/16 14:55 2023/6/16 14:55 35 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/16 14:55 2023/6/16 14:55 36 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/16 14:55 2023/6/16 14:55 37 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/16 15:03 2023/6/16 15:03 38 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/16 15:03 2023/6/16 15:03 39 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/16 15:03 2023/6/16 15:03 40 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/16 15:03 2023/6/16 15:03 41 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/16 16:42 2023/6/16 16:42 42 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/16 16:42 2023/6/16 16:42 43 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/16 16:42 2023/6/16 16:42 44 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/16 16:42 2023/6/16 16:42 45 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/16 17:01 2023/6/16 17:01 46 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/16 17:01 2023/6/16 17:01 47 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/16 17:01 2023/6/16 17:01 48 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/16 17:01 2023/6/16 17:01 49 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/16 18:17 2023/6/16 18:17 50 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/16 18:17 2023/6/16 18:17 51 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/16 18:17 2023/6/16 18:17 52 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/16 18:17 2023/6/16 18:17 53 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/16 18:37 2023/6/16 18:37 54 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/16 18:37 2023/6/16 18:37 55 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/16 18:37 2023/6/16 18:37 56 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/16 18:37 2023/6/16 18:37 57 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/16 18:54 2023/6/16 18:54 58 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/16 18:54 2023/6/16 18:54 59 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/16 18:54 2023/6/16 18:54 60 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/16 18:54 2023/6/16 18:54 61 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/16 19:15 2023/6/16 19:15 62 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/16 19:15 2023/6/16 19:15 63 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/16 19:15 2023/6/16 19:15 64 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/16 19:15 2023/6/16 19:15 65 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/17 16:10 2023/6/17 16:10 66 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/17 16:10 2023/6/17 16:10 67 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/17 16:10 2023/6/17 16:10 68 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/17 16:10 2023/6/17 16:10 69 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/17 19:14 2023/6/17 19:14 70 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/17 19:14 2023/6/17 19:14 71 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/17 19:14 2023/6/17 19:14 72 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/17 19:14 2023/6/17 19:14 73 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/19 10:36 2023/6/19 10:36 74 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/19 10:36 2023/6/19 10:36 75 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/19 10:36 2023/6/19 10:36 76 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/19 10:36 2023/6/19 10:36 77 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/19 10:57 2023/6/19 10:57 78 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/19 10:57 2023/6/19 10:57 79 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/19 10:57 2023/6/19 10:57 80 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/19 10:57 2023/6/19 10:57 81 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/19 11:22 2023/6/19 11:22 82 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/19 11:22 2023/6/19 11:22 83 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/19 11:22 2023/6/19 11:22 84 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/19 11:22 2023/6/19 11:22 85 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/19 12:04 2023/6/19 12:04 86 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/19 12:04 2023/6/19 12:04 87 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/19 12:04 2023/6/19 12:04 88 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/19 12:04 2023/6/19 12:04 89 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/19 12:21 2023/6/19 12:21 90 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/19 12:21 2023/6/19 12:21 91 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/19 12:21 2023/6/19 12:21 92 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/19 12:21 2023/6/19 12:21 93 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/19 12:35 2023/6/19 12:35 94 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/19 12:35 2023/6/19 12:35 95 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/19 12:35 2023/6/19 12:35 96 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/19 12:35 2023/6/19 12:35 97 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/19 16:03 2023/6/19 16:03 98 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/19 16:03 2023/6/19 16:03 99 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/19 16:03 2023/6/19 16:03 100 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/19 16:03 2023/6/19 16:03 101 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/19 17:23 2023/6/19 17:23 102 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/19 17:23 2023/6/19 17:23 103 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/19 17:23 2023/6/19 17:23 104 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/19 17:23 2023/6/19 17:23 105 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/19 17:54 2023/6/19 17:54 106 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/19 17:54 2023/6/19 17:54 107 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/19 17:54 2023/6/19 17:54 108 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/19 17:54 2023/6/19 17:54 109 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/19 18:23 2023/6/19 18:23 110 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/19 18:23 2023/6/19 18:23 111 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/19 18:23 2023/6/19 18:23 112 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/19 18:23 2023/6/19 18:23 113 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/21 15:56 2023/6/21 15:56 114 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/21 15:56 2023/6/21 15:56 115 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/21 15:56 2023/6/21 15:56 116 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/21 15:56 2023/6/21 15:56 117 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/21 16:05 2023/6/21 16:05 118 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/21 16:05 2023/6/21 16:05 119 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/21 16:05 2023/6/21 16:05 120 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/21 16:05 2023/6/21 16:05 121 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/21 16:27 2023/6/21 16:27 122 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/21 16:27 2023/6/21 16:27 123 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/21 16:27 2023/6/21 16:27 124 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/21 16:27 2023/6/21 16:27 125 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/21 18:30 2023/6/21 18:30 126 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/21 18:30 2023/6/21 18:30 127 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/21 18:30 2023/6/21 18:30 128 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/21 18:30 2023/6/21 18:30 129 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 09:48 2023/6/26 09:48 130 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 09:48 2023/6/26 09:48 131 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 09:48 2023/6/26 09:48 132 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 09:48 2023/6/26 09:48 133 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 10:07 2023/6/26 10:07 134 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 10:07 2023/6/26 10:07 135 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 10:07 2023/6/26 10:07 136 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 10:07 2023/6/26 10:07 137 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 10:51 2023/6/26 10:51 138 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 10:51 2023/6/26 10:51 139 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 10:51 2023/6/26 10:51 140 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 10:51 2023/6/26 10:51 141 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 11:32 2023/6/26 11:32 142 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 11:32 2023/6/26 11:32 143 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 11:32 2023/6/26 11:32 144 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 11:32 2023/6/26 11:32 145 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 12:02 2023/6/26 12:02 146 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 12:02 2023/6/26 12:02 147 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 12:02 2023/6/26 12:02 148 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 12:02 2023/6/26 12:02 149 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 14:24 2023/6/26 14:24 150 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 14:24 2023/6/26 14:24 151 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 14:24 2023/6/26 14:24 152 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 14:24 2023/6/26 14:24 153 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 14:43 2023/6/26 14:43 154 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 14:43 2023/6/26 14:43 155 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 14:43 2023/6/26 14:43 156 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 14:43 2023/6/26 14:43 157 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 14:56 2023/6/26 14:56 158 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 14:56 2023/6/26 14:56 159 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 14:56 2023/6/26 14:56 160 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 14:56 2023/6/26 14:56 161 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 15:10 2023/6/26 15:10 162 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 15:10 2023/6/26 15:10 163 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 15:10 2023/6/26 15:10 164 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 15:10 2023/6/26 15:10 165 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 16:38 2023/6/26 16:38 166 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 16:38 2023/6/26 16:38 167 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 16:38 2023/6/26 16:38 168 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 16:38 2023/6/26 16:38 169 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 16:53 2023/6/26 16:53 170 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 16:53 2023/6/26 16:53 171 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 16:53 2023/6/26 16:53 172 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/26 16:53 2023/6/26 16:53 173 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/27 10:43 2023/6/27 10:43 174 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_measure DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_measure` WHERE `id`='' didi0825 2023/6/27 10:43 2023/6/27 10:43 175 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/27 10:43 2023/6/27 10:43 176 000000000 delete hcevaluation30_evaluation DELETE FROM `hcevaluation30_evaluation` WHERE`id`='' didi0825 2023/6/27 10:43 2023/6/27 10:43
附表三：
編號 id action table_name cmd execute_user_id created_at updated_at 1 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='30' didi0825 2023/6/15 13:09 2023/6/15 13:09 2 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='338' didi0825 2023/6/15 16:18 2023/6/15 16:18 3 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='375' didi0825 2023/6/15 17:00 2023/6/15 17:00 4 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='339' didi0825 2023/6/15 17:22 2023/6/15 17:22 5 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='337' didi0825 2023/6/15 18:01 2023/6/15 18:01 6 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='357' didi0825 2023/6/15 18:37 2023/6/15 18:37 7 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='88' didi0825 2023/6/16 12:12 2023/6/16 12:12 8 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='32' didi0825 2023/6/16 13:00 2023/6/16 13:00 9 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='332' didi0825 2023/6/16 14:56 2023/6/16 14:56 10 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='21' didi0825 2023/6/16 15:02 2023/6/16 15:02 11 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='365' didi0825 2023/6/16 16:43 2023/6/16 16:43 12 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='94' didi0825 2023/6/16 17:02 2023/6/16 17:02 13 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='46' didi0825 2023/6/16 18:17 2023/6/16 18:17 14 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='376' didi0825 2023/6/16 18:37 2023/6/16 18:37 15 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='203' didi0825 2023/6/16 19:05 2023/6/16 19:05 16 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='360' didi0825 2023/6/16 19:16 2023/6/16 19:16 17 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='363' didi0825 2023/6/17 16:11 2023/6/17 16:11 18 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='68' didi0825 2023/6/17 19:15 2023/6/17 19:15 19 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='67' didi0825 2023/6/19 10:36 2023/6/19 10:36 20 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='374' didi0825 2023/6/19 10:58 2023/6/19 10:58 21 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='373' didi0825 2023/6/19 11:23 2023/6/19 11:23 22 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='40' didi0825 2023/6/19 12:05 2023/6/19 12:05 23 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='89' didi0825 2023/6/19 12:22 2023/6/19 12:22 24 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='178' didi0825 2023/6/19 12:36 2023/6/19 12:36 25 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='362' didi0825 2023/6/19 16:13 2023/6/19 16:13 26 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='343' didi0825 2023/6/19 17:24 2023/6/19 17:24 27 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='22' didi0825 2023/6/19 17:56 2023/6/19 17:56 28 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='31' didi0825 2023/6/19 18:23 2023/6/19 18:23 29 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='383' didi0825 2023/6/21 15:56 2023/6/21 15:56 30 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='283' didi0825 2023/6/21 16:03 2023/6/21 16:03 31 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='313' didi0825 2023/6/21 16:28 2023/6/21 16:28 32 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='372' didi0825 2023/6/21 18:31 2023/6/21 18:31 33 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='323' didi0825 2023/6/26 09:48 2023/6/26 09:48 34 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='281' didi0825 2023/6/26 10:08 2023/6/26 10:08 35 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='275' didi0825 2023/6/26 10:51 2023/6/26 10:51 36 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='314' didi0825 2023/6/26 11:32 2023/6/26 11:32 37 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='239' didi0825 2023/6/26 12:02 2023/6/26 12:02 38 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='330' didi0825 2023/6/26 14:25 2023/6/26 14:25 39 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='368' didi0825 2023/6/26 14:44 2023/6/26 14:44 40 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='361' didi0825 2023/6/26 14:57 2023/6/26 14:57 41 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='243' didi0825 2023/6/26 15:10 2023/6/26 15:10 42 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='347' didi0825 2023/6/26 16:39 2023/6/26 16:39 43 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='227' didi0825 2023/6/26 16:53 2023/6/26 16:53 44 000000000 delete inpatientinfo DELETE FROM `inpatientinfo` WHERE `patientID`='244' didi0825 2023/6/27 10:44 2023/6/27 10:44
附表四：
證據出處 一、人證部分： ㈠證人林芝柔112年10月25日偵訊筆錄暨證人結文（他卷第67至77、79頁） ㈡證人林芝柔113年3月12日偵訊筆錄暨證人結文（他卷第111至116、121頁） ㈢證人林芝柔113年11月5日偵訊筆錄（偵卷第65至68頁） ㈣證人蔡定綸113年4月9日偵訊筆錄暨證人結文（他卷第179至182、183頁） ㈤證人王宛琳113年3月12日偵訊筆錄暨證人結文（他卷第111至116、117頁） ㈥證人方俊富113年3月12日偵訊筆錄暨證人結文（他卷第111至116、119頁） 二、書證部分： ㈠馥柔居家護理所之電腦系統資料庫之操作紀錄（他卷第9至33頁） ㈡諾亞克公司報價單、長照資訊系統登錄頁面截圖（他卷第123至125頁） ㈢辯護人提出被告與諾亞克公司LINE應用程式對話截圖（本院卷一第57頁） ㈣諾亞克科技股份有限公司114年10月14日諾法字第11410001號函（本院卷一第75至81頁） ㈤衛生福利部中央健康保險署南區業務組114年10月20日健保南醫字第1148506270號函（本院卷一第83至91頁） ㈥居家照護案件申報受理作業全民健康保險居家照護申請書等之資料影本（本院卷一第125至131頁） ㈦告訴人林芝柔提出之護理資料遭刪除紀錄明細表（本院卷二第315至440頁） ㈧告訴人林芝柔提出之所使用之諾亞克長照資訊系統遭刪除長照服務對象所屬護理資料後之電腦畫面截圖（本院卷二第7至229頁） ㈨告訴人林芝柔提出之馥柔居家護理所使用之諾亞克長照資訊系統登錄長照服務對象人數名冊（本院卷二第231至303頁） ㈩告訴人林芝柔提出之馥柔居家護理所使用諾亞克長照資訊系統長照服務對象之護理計畫「無被刪除資料之電腦畫面」截圖1份（本院卷二第305至313頁） 資料表所對應之系統表單及其刪除資料內容說明書（本院卷一第155至159頁） 三、被告部分： ㈠被告許佳琪112年11月7日第一次偵訊筆錄（他卷第87至88頁） ㈡被告許佳琪112年11月7日第二次偵訊筆錄（他卷第91至92頁） ㈢被告許佳琪113年8月6日偵訊筆錄（交查卷第9至15頁） ㈣被告許佳琪113年11月5日偵訊筆錄（偵卷第65至68頁） ㈤被告許佳琪114年6月17日準備程序筆錄（本院卷一第39至53頁） ㈥被告許佳琪115年1月27日準備程序筆錄（本院卷一第111至124頁） ㈦被告許佳琪115年7月9日審理程序之供述（本院卷一第177至194頁）