lawpalyer logo
in判決書

高雄高等行政法院 高等庭(含改制前高雄高等行政法院)103年度訴字第171號

關鍵資訊

  • 裁判案由
    營利事業所得稅
  • 案件類型
    行政
  • 審判法院
    高雄高等行政法院 高等庭(含改制前高雄高等行政法院)
  • 裁判日期
    103 年 12 月 24 日

1031711031210              10321800000000000 100 80,773,11596101 79,230,85079,230,8501,542,265 調1951231 39.2295調 26.4524.1995調14.931:1.77229613 154.05142.48TFT-LCD 1 96132.85×95 123124.1968.9444.051:3.2353 961316.03×958.86 142.0390.75 1:1.5701:1.5701:3.23521:2.297 1:2.297 TFT-LCD Sang Bo Corporation SBK TFT-LCD LCD LCD 9552,575,00095675,104,000 95沿8993194 4 使 89931 944 2.24 3.01 162.65 121.26 18.88 11.52 19.33 31.68 3.45 5.42 105.80 67.34 18.24 6.07 0.89 1.02 17.05 15.33 43.40 27.55 12.03 12.94 8.86 9.35 SBK SBK Multi-Function optical film Keiwa 巿 100121 103725102 44910372545 96109710012196 10387 399495103876 1001219610 10387 9510387796412 521 103822968.6%8.6%7 95313095045094502517100121 ZXY9531309504509450 2517100121X-Y = Z X Y Z Z 1038745 Z 103822YXZ 1038223 Z Z + Y = X AB1295313095045094502517100121 ()1 10382234稿25 - ()2 31,456,12072,875,18010382245稿95129696800稿Bean Mode Optronics LLC.BMO95123149,000,0009693067,000,000.9512-72,875,180 - 調500 American Appraisal 1038221819242565 International Valuation Standards CouncilInternational Valuation Standards A. B. 調 C. 96101 /82007MorningStarMarket Size Premium調 100 Mergerstat Review 14743.2 30100×-30.0 100 100×43.2 ×-30.0 1038229610-12400,00097500,00098600,00099700,000 6 9610-12 400,000 5 99,726400,000 9610-12400,00056 ()9610-12400,00097500,000 98600,00099700,00097-100961012118,538 97155,2669899100SBK 貿 ()49964 96調 9696 10.854-55 1.5 SBK SBK 1.5 1031031 退28//322 調()123 7 調1031031 調調調1031031()35 調調228 使調Multiples 調調調103102314 調調調調調調調調調調調1031023 10310319810910310231Mergerstat Review 35%50%28%45%Mergerstat Review 43.2% 17.87%..()45調1010310232MergerStat Review Unaffected Stock Price10MergerStat Review 17.87%1010310232MergerStat Review Mergerstat Review Mergerstat Review 1031023 1031031:1.5%7 2 10.8% 1.5%12.3% 1.5%β(Bloomberg) BetaBeta661 2961104 5 101 290 662 9961 96412 96521 9910012 2518100121100 80,773,11596101 527,117,984 130,963,733396,154,2515 10079,230,850 1,542,265 96101 3,561,608 96929148527,117,984130,963,733396,154,2515 1 95123139.22(95調26.45)24.19(95調14.93)1:1.77229613154.05142.48TFT-LCD ()1 96132.85×951231 24.19=68.9444.051:3.2353961316.03×958.86=142.03 90.751:1.5701:1.570~1:3.23521:2.297 9613× 9556191:2.297 調1:2.297 6496929148/2.2979696461026201-202 2.5 64 96112696101 9610231400000000175-200 調9696101 1.8%2101-11 15.81%1:2.297 10012 1 2518American Appraisal97100 96101 97100 396,154,251 118,612,191100,000,0009999203-208 XYZXYZYXZ [P/EP/B ] 9672571.57-3.235) 96132.8516.03 1.2.調1.2.調調調1.2.3.4.1819242565調P/EP/B(28-30) 528,618,798 46.35-54.489594 2.111,685,25245,360,876 95107,279,781 2,713,026100,747,9563,818,799 103872427-28959410387 39774,58841,102,740 129,887,13935,710,858 76,069,4703,588,384 96930533,005,420貿673,818,3521038755-58 467,899,230 9495 - 72,875,180959413210 951231,456,120BMO 100%100%BMO 31,456,12072,875,1802.3 - 12.3103 20144196(96 1196930961011.8%97100(218,612,191)9610-12400,00097500,00098600,00099700,00097-10096 1012118,53897155,2669899100 203-206 554,898,526239,165,583315,732,943 94951.37%2.97%1.587196412 1.5871148 93148/1.587 961011.5871964-6102696201-202 959.03%96 1.8%53.7% 退97-1009796319899100 SBK 527,117,984130,963,733 968.6%8.6%971009610197100 396,154,251 118,612,191 100,000,00099 99203-204 1031016 1038221819242565XZ退28P/EP/B322 調 International Valuation Standards CouncilIntern ational Valuation Standards 調調調調2007MorningStar 調Mergerstat Review 43.2-30[1.432×1-0.31.00 24] 20889520調98109 Mergerstat Review 35502845Mergerstat Review43.2 17.87 13.71 17.87 調1.1787×1-0.30.825 101810- 調1034調調調調1031016 調 1031016 10.854-55 1.5 SBK SBK 1.5 1.5 54WACCKeCAPMKeRfβαββKe13.5 1 23456 ()2 100 79,230,850 100 80,773,11596101 527,117,984 130,963,733396,154,251510079,230,8501,542,265 100 100 79,230,8501001,542,265 1 3 5 24160196134 953130950450945068913668100329791026257 68 125調 100 121 25182518使961 1017951001403 96101 96457 2465- 6773-76951231 1 2.29712.297 3,561,608 527,117,984 130,963,733396,154,251510079,230,8502 91945619939560,738,603118,206,198298,617,11795%153%1,391,3482.29%8,177,9266.91%32,260,68011%9512BMO100% 貿100%368-370210217221 95123196930 130,963,733 175-200951130 252517101 2 18181 2 3 4使 使使5 6 7 95961125171012退退18181 2 3 4 5 使使6 7 8 9 1025130,963,733 88132 25 調3737291112152.1 2 9.311.1 2 12. 使15. 使 37 37SBK CNC11560使97550 SBK SBK 113 371595302:93%46%200893%21%200993%10%2010100%125 127 SBK SBK9611 SBK 93%116125 Broadwell Worldwide Limited.BroadwellBMO100%BMO 100%9594951231,456,120BMO100% 95BMO31,456,120Broadwell23,904,57555,360,69 5210BMO 調BMO 96800 BMO BMO951231 4,900969306,700969307,200調 72,875,180250BMO9512314,90031,456,120 BMO100% BMO 6,700 7,200BMO 96930BMO959693088 P/EP/B調1 2.297 2.1542.697155.8554,898,526 1033214 415316172731.2.3. 1.2.稿1.2.3.4.5.調6.7.調調 7 調7 4 調9520調417247調調調 P/EP/BP/E P/B 4 172 調12.2971 2.297 554,898,526 527,117,984 396,154,2513.02396,154,251/130,963,7331.3315,732,943/239,165,58393951,391,3482.29%8,177,9266.91%32,260,68011% 13135 96101 100 79,230,8501,5 42,265 981         103    12    24               2020 24111 12 1.             2. 3. 1. 2. 3. 4.         103    12    24